fast-auth-signer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
fast-auth-signer copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon near

Cannot do Near.call to thirdparty contracts using FastAuth-created account

Open frol opened this issue 2 years ago • 7 comments

Describe the bug

FastAuth-created account cannot sign transactions to third-party contracts on near.org, so if users go with the cool feature of near.org, they become hostages unable to interact with DevHub or any other BOS app that uses a custom contract (not social.near) even if they fund the account as signing with full-access key does not work.

To Reproduce

  1. Sign into FastAuth-created account
  2. Go to DevHub: https://near.org/devgovgigs.near/widget/gigs-board.pages.Feed
  3. Try to like or post something
  4. You won't be able to submit the transaction

Expected behavior

I should be able to sign a transaction to third-party contracts (non-social.near), and get the transaction relayed or prompted to fund my account with some NEAR to cover the fees.

Screenshots

Here is the video recording: https://www.loom.com/share/22744a79b3b54e56a9eae1ba7264977b

frol avatar Oct 23 '23 19:10 frol

Thanks for filing this issue @frol ! I ran into the same paint points when onboarding ecosystem contributors to DevHub recently, as they could not interact with the platform via FastAuth accounts. 😞

It would be ideal if we could prioritize this issue as it's a critical developer engagement piece for the NEAR ecosystem.

@trechriron should this issue be transferred to fast-auth-signer or mentioned in a newly created one in that repo?

cc @DavidM-D @diogoortega

thisisjoshford avatar Oct 23 '23 19:10 thisisjoshford

I have added to the Fast Auth project board in Triage status. We regularly look through defects and determine priority, severity, and assignment.

trechriron avatar Oct 23 '23 19:10 trechriron

Actually, I need to transfer it so it shows properly. I suggest we submit all fast-auth defects to the #fast-auth-signer repo in the future. Thanks!

trechriron avatar Oct 23 '23 19:10 trechriron

As of 11/15/2023, I'm able to create a post from a FastAuth account:

txn: https://legacy.explorer.near.org/transactions/DhDSuYixjYtEXfEKTmLtV8Gq2qSVTfsBL5aywEXftsGE#5i9MsvG74eyVm5SooTbnrQWTSqLPtnJQkNy7Cit37FTu

result post: https://near.social/devhub.near/widget/app?page=post&id=2129

But it is quite volatile, took me about 5 attempts to successfully submit this transaction. Unlike post from a wallet account, which is always successful

ailisp avatar Nov 15 '23 02:11 ailisp

@DavidM-D Is this issue fixed?

ailisp avatar Nov 15 '23 02:11 ailisp

@hcho112 is this still an issue? Do you know why transaction submission is so unstable? Is it reproducible?

volovyks avatar Dec 12 '23 15:12 volovyks

Just ran into that @trechriron @volovyks any updates on this one?

flmel avatar Feb 13 '24 15:02 flmel