pandoc icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pandoc copied to clipboard

Support TiddlyWiki syntax

Open ghost opened this issue 6 years ago • 12 comments

Can you please implement conversion from tiddlywiki format to markdown

ghost avatar Mar 06 '19 14:03 ghost

Apparently, they call their syntax WikiText

mb21 avatar Mar 06 '19 15:03 mb21

Seconded, as per my issue, #6602.

Atlas48 avatar Aug 09 '20 13:08 Atlas48

I second this also. That's quite unique piece of software; very convenient in everyday use. And it's interoperability is great - in most cases, it's just one html file.

@mb21, they call they syntax WikiText, but it has some differences from, for example, MediaWiki.

dbobak avatar Sep 14 '20 01:09 dbobak

It would be great to support this. I've moved to Drift (a TiddlyWiki custom distribution) exclusively for my personal and professional information management, but for very large amounts of text, I still prefer to use IA Writer (Markdown). Cut and paste is not ideal but I still think it's acceptable if we could get this conversion natively. Thank you!

RamXX avatar Oct 17 '20 17:10 RamXX

Can I offer 10 bucks to that.

ghost avatar Dec 25 '20 16:12 ghost

I certainly will offer 10 bucks for all spammers to shut up.

ickc avatar Dec 25 '20 19:12 ickc

I agree that I'd rather not read spammy messages. I'd also like to ask everybody to keep it civil, please.

tarleb avatar Dec 25 '20 19:12 tarleb

I agree that I'd rather not read spammy messages. I'd also like to ask everybody to keep it civil, please.

I'm not spammer. I'm just a tiddlywiki user. I just wanted to donate some bucks to speed the solution of this bug but the responses I saw.... it disappointed me.

ghost avatar Dec 26 '20 14:12 ghost

I believe that your comment was written with good intentions. But let me suggest some alternatives:

  1. Want to help financially? Make an unconditional donation.
  2. Want to pay for the feature? Ask for a quote.
  3. Show appreciation on a budget? Offer to buy a drink or just say "thanks"!

The message was received as spammy because it seems to contain the hope for preferable treatment, and the investment of a significant amount of dev time, in exchange for a tip. It gives the impression that the work which goes into this is undervalued.

To offer a rough idea of the effort that will be required, we can take a look at Jira support. It took about 6 weeks of early-morning, evening, and weekend work to get acceptable quality of conversion. This was followed by many hours of bug fixing once Jira support had landed in pandoc and the feature was used on more documents. I'd estimate that it took well north of 60 hours to get it all done. I hope this makes it clearer why a small amount of money, offered as an external motivator, is doomed to be extremely ineffective.

tarleb avatar Dec 26 '20 15:12 tarleb

As a heads up: I've started on working on a TiddlyWiki writer. Looking at the history, it seems like new writers are added as a single commit, so I'll wait to open a PR till it's complete.

joshkunz avatar Mar 26 '21 22:03 joshkunz

For who wanna convert markdown to tiddlywiki, i implement a lua plugin to do this. Check following

https://github.com/jeffrey4l/pandoc-addons

There is also a tiddlywiki support convernt tiddlywiki to markdown

https://cdaven.github.io/tiddlywiki/

jeffrey4l avatar Oct 17 '22 03:10 jeffrey4l

From a comment it does sound like this is in progress, thank you for that.

Until that is complete, have found a work around. Import the markdown plugin to your tiddlywiki, and then convert to markdown format. Just make sure to set type to Markdown.

toadico avatar Feb 11 '24 20:02 toadico