waypoints icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
waypoints copied to clipboard

Sticky without jQuery dependency

Open vovayatsyuk opened this issue 10 years ago • 12 comments

I've added methods to work with classes (can't use classList because of IE9,10) and proxy method to Sticky object.

vovayatsyuk avatar Apr 03 '15 08:04 vovayatsyuk

I could be game for adding noframework support for the sticky shortcut, but I'd need a couple things to change:

  • It's already confusing enough that there are 3 builds of the core library. I'd rather not have multiple builds of the shortcuts. I know this would require a pretty big refactoring of how your current implementation works.
  • Sticky tests need to also run against the noframework adapter. They currently only run against the jQuery adapter.

I know those may be some big asks with very little direction. If you would like to give that a shot, that would be awesome. If not I can leave this as a feature enhancement request.

imakewebthings avatar Apr 16 '15 15:04 imakewebthings

@imakewebthings have to disagree with you there. This PR follows the established patterns of the project, and @vovayatsyuk is following that pattern responsibly. I do agree with your point about this needing to run against the proper tests - that's a must have. But if that were implemented, I don't feel it's reasonable to ask a PR author to refactor your project just to submit a fix where the fix is valid, needed, and would be welcomed by the community.

shellscape avatar Nov 18 '15 12:11 shellscape

@shellscape Allow me to clarify.

I know those may be some big asks with very little direction. If you would like to give that a shot, that would be awesome. If not I can leave this as a feature enhancement request.

I realize I didn't communicate this, but by "leaving this as a feature enhancement request" what I mean is that, when I do get around to merging this, I can finish making the changes necessary for this to be released.

imakewebthings avatar Nov 18 '15 15:11 imakewebthings

Hey @imakewebthings Thanks for the project, any status updates for this merge? Do we think it will eventually be merged in?

mpolichette avatar Feb 12 '16 23:02 mpolichette

please check-in :+1:

thematan avatar Apr 26 '16 12:04 thematan

@thematan My newborn son continues to grow, remain healthy, and delight me every single day for the few precious hours I get to spend with him. Thank you for asking!

@mpolichette This PR or something like it will be merged eventually and part of 5.0.

imakewebthings avatar May 04 '16 13:05 imakewebthings

Hey ya'll, any progress on this? I could use it too and it's passing tests. Would appreciate any work getting it through, thank you!

sdras avatar Jun 14 '16 19:06 sdras

Thanks for all the hard work @imakewebthings! 👍 ❤️ waypoints.

ericnkatz avatar Jul 29 '16 15:07 ericnkatz

any possibility of getting this merged in?

FranciscoG avatar Jun 06 '18 02:06 FranciscoG

@FranciscoG way to raise this one from the dead. there have to be better alternatives out there by now, surely.

shellscape avatar Jun 06 '18 03:06 shellscape

@shellscape Would those alternatives (if those exist) work for say Gridsome/Vue?

Berkmann18 avatar Jan 07 '20 13:01 Berkmann18

@Berkmann18 I've no idea. I haven't used this project in years.

shellscape avatar Jan 07 '20 13:01 shellscape