openwhisk-wskdeploy

openwhisk-wskdeploy copied to clipboard

basically have two triggers tied to same action, where i am trying to pass the inputs from triggers to the action. right now the action doesn't recognize the value of these trigger arguments.

followed the pattern on this site.

https://github.com/apache/incubator-openwhisk-wskdeploy/blob/master/docs/wskdeploy_triggerrule_trigger_bindings.md#triggers-and-rules

also this is what it says as far as my packages when i run "bx wsk package list"

packages /adam-johnson-sandbox_walmart-watering-dev/walmart_watering private /adam-johnson-sandbox_walmart-watering-dev/Bluemix_walmart-watering-dev-db_wsk private

can't attach yamls so stored in zip file the manifest and deploy.yml files yamls.zip

Once the trigger is defined as alarm type, the trigger inputs are not propagated to actions:

I modified manifest to:

    triggers:
      meetPerson:
        feed: /whisk.system/alarms/alarm
        inputs:
          name: string
          place: string
          children: integer
          height: float

deployment to:

            inputs:
              name: Elrond
              place: Rivendell
              children: 3
              height: 1.88
              cron: "0 7 29,30 6 *"

wsk activation returns:

        "result": {
            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello,  from "
        }

instead of:

        "result": {
            "details": "You have 3 children and are 1.88 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello, Elrond from Rivendell"
        }

the same behavior is seen with wsk CLI:

wsk trigger create my-alarm-trigger-1 --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param name Priti --param place Home --param cron "* * * * *"

Creating rule:

wsk rule create my-rule-1 my-alarm-trigger-1 hello_world_package/hello_world_triggerrule

Fire trigger:

wsk trigger fire my-alarm-trigger-1

Result had no name and place assigned:

wsk activation get 1b150c7339ab4074950c7339ab40741a ... "result": {
            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello,  from "

V/S Non Feed Trigger:

wsk trigger create my-no-alarm-trigger --param name Priti --param place Home

Creating rule with:

wsk rule create my-rule-2 my-no-alarm-trigger hello_world_package/hello_world_triggerrule

Fire trigger and check the result:

            "details": "You have 0 children and are 0 m. tall.",
            "greeting": "Hello, Priti from Home"
        }

Confirmed with @beemarie that it does work through IBM Cloud Functions UI.

@pritidesai @beemarie

With alarm feed you need to use the parameter trigger_payload

For example:

wsk trigger create my-alarm-trigger-1 --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param cron "30 2 * * *" --param trigger_payload "{\"name\":\"Priti\",\"place\":\"Home\"}"

More info in the alarm docs: https://github.com/apache/incubator-openwhisk-package-alarms#firing-a-trigger-on-a-time-based-schedule-using-cron

thanks @csantanapr I talked to @dubee and tried the same with trigger_payload without any success:

Trigger create with:

wsk trigger create locationUpdate --param name Odin --param place Asgard

Creates parameters under Parameters section in UI

But when I create alarm trigger with:

wsk trigger create periodic --feed /whisk.system/alarms/alarm --param cron "*/2 * * * *" --param trigger_payload "{\"name\":\"Odin\",\"place\":\"Asgard\"}"

doesnt show any parameters in UI

It does show payload on trigger with:

wsk trigger get periodic
   "response": {
        "result": {
            "config": {
                "cron": "*/2 * * * *",
                "name": "periodic",
                "namespace": "",
                "payload": {
                    "name": "Odin",
                    "place": "Asgard"
                }
            },

the action should also show the trigger_payload. It will be under a param called payload though just as it shows for trigger get.

@jasonpet nope action doesn't show such parameter, also, @dubee referenced couple of issues from CLI repo ...