get-installed-related-apps icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
get-installed-related-apps copied to clipboard

fingerprinting concerns

Open pes10k opened this issue 5 years ago • 2 comments

I don't follow the claim about non-fingerprint-ability. If I'm a company with a large number of apps (e.g. google), with 16-32 apps registered in app stores, the subset of which apps any user has installed is likely to be a very strong semi-identifier, no, and so be extremely risky for the user / valuable for the fingerprinter, no?

Apologies if I'm misunderstanding, but this seems like a very clear privacy risk.

Put differently, if this isn't a privacy risk, whats the rational behind disallowing this in private browsing mode?

pes10k avatar Nov 22 '19 22:11 pes10k

whats the rational behind disallowing this in private browsing mode

The concern was that if a website can know that the corresponding native app is installed, it might force users to use that native version instead and make them leave their private browsing mode. It also falls in line with private browsing expectations.

This would be a privacy improvement to 100% of origins, at the expense of providing a privacy mode detector with a non-negligible false positive rate to a very very small percentage of origins.

rayankans avatar Nov 28 '19 15:11 rayankans

I just learned about this API and I have similar concerns to @pes10k , but I think that the attack surface might be even bigger because of the app version being leaked. Consider:

kdzwinel avatar Oct 21 '20 10:10 kdzwinel