s3-practical-guide icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
s3-practical-guide copied to clipboard

missing serial commas

Open wolftune opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

I fixed one in https://github.com/S3-working-group/s3-practical-guide/pull/4

but rather than just submit more PRs (having not gotten a reply there yet), I'm opening this to point out cases of missing serial commas for consideration:

  • under "Basic Concepts": "Drivers, Value and Waste" and "Domains, Delegation and Accountability" both seem to need the serial comma.

Without the serial comma, it can be read like "Drivers: Value and Waste" and "Domains: Delegation and Accountability". I don't think that's the intention (but if it is, the colon would be better).

wolftune avatar Oct 04 '19 22:10 wolftune

Another case:

"The Principle of Consent: Raise, seek out and resolve objections to decisions and actions."

The serial comma would go after "seek out,"

However, I'd suggest an easier to parse definition:

"The Principle of Consent: Raise and seek out objections to decisions and actions. Then, work to resolve them."

or similar. That is longer but easier to read and to follow as a pattern.

wolftune avatar Oct 04 '19 22:10 wolftune

Value is the importance, worth or usefulness…

wolftune avatar Oct 04 '19 23:10 wolftune

a unit, department, team or individuals

wolftune avatar Oct 04 '19 23:10 wolftune