immich
immich copied to clipboard
immich-app
[TECH-DEBT] Mobile upload refactor
Now that the support for client-side hashing has been merged into the server.
It is time to look at some long-standing issues with uploading assets from the mobile app that have been reported, such as
- [x] Negative remainder count.
- [ ] Client-side hashing on the mobile app to check duplicates before uploading.
- [ ] Better error handling on a failed upload
- [x] Some mobile devices cannot scan for album
The plan is to refactor the uploading code to make it cleaner as well as include new hashing and error handling mechanism
May I add some things? I don't know if they're in scope of this issue:
- Files getting stuck in the upload queue. Restart of the app will prompt to re-upload the file (even on cellular network)
- Backup starts even when on cellular network.
- Scanning for assets sometimes takes multiple hours, seemingly doing nothing. If it is not, feel free to ignore my suggestions.
I would also love to see two way sync, so that if I delete a photo on the web it also gets removed on my phone. Maybe one could implement an out of sync warning like GPhotos does 😁
@Vcele That would be a separate feature which we will implement in the future
May I add some things? I don't know if they're in scope of this issue:
- Files getting stuck in the upload queue. Restart of the app will prompt to re-upload the file (even on cellular network)
- Backup starts even when on cellular network.
- Scanning for assets sometimes takes multiple hours, seemingly doing nothing. If it is not, feel free to ignore my suggestions.
it seems #1 is linked to file size. 1GB or more is suspect.
I just came across something which I orignally never thought of. I myself don't have this, but my direct family does. They have albums on their phones which span over multiple years. It is currently absolutely impossible to add all these pictures manually to the album that has to be manually created within immich. The photos cross around many years. If, the albums were directly created on upload and the the assets automatically added (Also future assets for that album), that would make immich so incredibly powerful for mobile backups.
Originated from general discussion within discord.
I just wanted to add another thing, to attach a tag to the photo with the name of the album/folder it came from, so you could later create a album or filter out just the pictures that you took (DCIM>Camera) or screenshots (DCIM>Screenshots).
I would also love to see two way sync, so that if I delete a photo on the web it also gets removed on my phone. Maybe one could implement an out of sync warning like GPhotos does grin
Please make this feature optional :upside_down_face:
I too have experienced the negative counter, is there any way to fix it? As it's negative, it's unclear if any photos still need to be backed up or not
@codeinabox you can fix it by either clear the app cache or reinstall the app
Please consider option to pause a current upload. This is useful when the user is in an area with low cell coverage, and takes a video. I had barely any service, and shot a video. Immich kept trying to upload that video for hours, consuming all of the little bandwidth i had.
Peeking in :) ( I love this project )
These features would be amazing, and is the only thing stopping me from downloading Immich on all of my devices at the moment.
Downloading Immich on multiple IOS devices leads to the entire library having to be re-synced. (even though duplicates aren't created. Waiting on the full file uploads for a MD5 Hash check is killing a ton of time)
With the recent launch of external libraries, this would be amazing for quickly syncing iCloud. (as I recently corrupted my Immich Postgres database & have had to resync my app. (leading to the same upload/hash check loop)
Update: This is probably a better issue for me to track on my end: https://github.com/orgs/immich-app/projects/1/views/1?pane=issue&itemId=29492098
Peeking in :) ( I love this project )
These features would be amazing, and is the only thing stopping me from downloading Immich on all of my devices at the moment.
Downloading Immich on multiple IOS devices leads to the entire library having to be re-synced. (even though duplicates aren't created. Waiting on the full file uploads for a MD5 Hash check is killing a ton of time)
With the recent launch of external libraries, this would be amazing for quickly syncing iCloud. (as I recently corrupted my Immich Postgres database & have had to resync my app. (leading to the same upload/hash check loop)
Update: This is probably a better issue for me to track on my end: https://github.com/orgs/immich-app/projects/1/views/1?pane=issue&itemId=29492098
@alexchomiak You can indeed sync iCloud by binding the photo.photolibrary-Originals folder as a read-only external library in Immich, enable the watcher and it will sync automatically, though some exif-less photo's creation date will be wrong because its based on the date its synced from icloud, and not its original capture date.
consuming all of the little bandwidth i had.
Like whe ln you're in a tourism area taking pictures? Yes, a snooze or pause button the notification would be very nice. This could be a separate issue.
Posting live from use case #jungfrau
Hey there, I'm not sure if this issue has already been reported, at least I didn't find a similar issue. On my Android phone, the synchronization doesn't seem to work properly. For about 2 weeks, my phone has been trying to sync my photos and Videos (I didn't take any new) and the counter of to be synced Videos sometimes increases, but stays at around 624. Also, it seems that the app continues to sync with mobile data, even though this option is disabled (the app used 9GB of mobile data this month lol)
Are you aware of these issues? Do you need any additional information?
It would be great to add the feature to select upload destination for mobile app for users have more than one device, eg iphone, ipad, android phones
