waypoints icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
waypoints copied to clipboard

Is this project still Active?

Open glennphilp opened this issue 6 years ago • 13 comments

I noticed there haven't been any updates in 2-years. I am looking for a scrolling JavaScript library similar to ScrollMagic or Skrollr. However, none seem to be actively developed. And so far don't incorporate with WebPack builds very well.

glennphilp avatar Mar 19 '18 20:03 glennphilp

Sadly, it looks like it is dead and he doesn't appear to be active on Github at all. His contributions page shows only 4 contributions over the last year.

There are over 1200 forks of waypoints, so it is very popular! Unfortunately, there doesn't appear to be an easy way to see which one(s) are currently active.

BryanH avatar Apr 17 '18 15:04 BryanH

Also, taking a look at the project, it's pretty fast and solid as it is in the 4.0.1. I haven't any troubles incorporating in my projects so far, and I've been using this guy for over two years.

Anyway, did you find a project that's being actively developed?

Shirkit avatar Apr 26 '18 19:04 Shirkit

Really liked waypoints! But, just evaluating https://github.com/stutrek/scrollMonitor, seems quite stable and solid too. But does not offer all the convenience waypoints had, for example out of the box pinning, or percentage offsets.

benzkji avatar May 10 '18 06:05 benzkji

Ok, I'm one of those who asked, and worried about waypoints health, so I tried up scrollMonitor, but honestly, waypoints is still by far the better tool of this kind out there. It has all the utilities functions and options one could need. One short thing of scrollMonitor, for example, is that you can only set the offset in pixels, not percentage, nor one of the other 3 methods (5 in total) waypoints exposes. So...

Go for waypoints for now. Absolutely.

Hope it helps some new comers to avoid loose their time trying other libraries. Cheers.

stratboy avatar Nov 06 '18 12:11 stratboy

There's also this: https://semantic-ui.com/behaviors/visibility.html

brendon avatar Dec 06 '18 04:12 brendon

I believe Waypoints is so robust at this point that there’s no need to develop it further — unless a bug comes along the way. ScrollMagic and Skrollr are made for an entirely different use-case (execute Javascript AS you scroll, while Waypoints executes Javascript ONCE you scroll to something), so I wouldn’t get those two confused.

chrisjansky avatar Dec 07 '18 12:12 chrisjansky

There is at least one bug. I have PR open for it (no test yet though): https://github.com/imakewebthings/waypoints/pull/509, #508

brendon avatar Dec 07 '18 19:12 brendon

Perhaps @imakewebthings, could hand on maintenance of this repo to someone else?

brendon avatar Dec 07 '18 19:12 brendon

Perhaps @imakewebthings, could hand on maintenance of this repo to someone else?

Or simply add collaborators.

Berkmann18 avatar Jan 07 '20 13:01 Berkmann18

What about IntersectionObserver https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Intersection_Observer_API? This might make waypoints redundant.

osopolar avatar Feb 27 '20 19:02 osopolar

not really redundant, but the remaining work is really not that hard anymore :-) @osopolar

benzkji avatar Mar 01 '20 21:03 benzkji

What about IntersectionObserver https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Intersection_Observer_API? This might make waypoints redundant.

If this approach interests you, check out scrollama.

Arithmomaniac avatar Jul 27 '20 12:07 Arithmomaniac

Scrollama appears to be quite good!

Andreas-Schoenefeldt avatar Nov 23 '21 09:11 Andreas-Schoenefeldt