fheroes2 icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
fheroes2 copied to clipboard

Battle screen, Medusa's "Petrification" requires a new icon

Open Branikolog opened this issue 3 years ago • 19 comments

Preliminary checks

Describe the problem requiring a solution

Currently we have a original icon for this effect. But its design is poor and ugly image We also need this icon to be shown in spell description window: image

Describe the possible solution

A nice starting issue for an artist. An icon should be created using Heroes 2 palettes. It can look, for example, like some sort of stone object or similar to current implementation figure made of stone. Also, it can be a picture of medusa's face, as the effect is inspired by the medusa's ability to turn creatures into a stone.

Additional info

No response

Branikolog avatar Oct 07 '21 15:10 Branikolog

Hello @Branikolog,

In the original game, they used the wrong color for the background of the Medusa petrification sprite, which makes this squared border around the sprite. This can be easily fixed by simply changing the background color. (This bug is reported in this thread (SPELLINL.ICN, 0011.bmp): https://heroes2.forumactif.com/t303-changes-to-the-game-s-graphics.) Also, I think this sprite doesn't look so bad once the correction is made.

In original game (with the sprite corrected): Medusa stone effect 01 Medusa stone effect 02

LeHerosInconnu avatar Oct 07 '21 16:10 LeHerosInconnu

I'm thinking of using a head icon that is half turned to stone like this image image.

The icons shall be based off the blind spell icons image

cxong avatar Oct 26 '21 09:10 cxong

Hi, @cxong. Sounds good! I think, head should be facing left, so it would more distinctive from "Blind".

Branikolog avatar Oct 26 '21 12:10 Branikolog

Hello @cxong and @Branikolog,

I'm thinking of using a head icon that is half turned to stone like this image image.

The icons shall be based off the blind spell icons image

Hi, @cxong. Sounds good! I think, head should be facing left, so it would more distinctive from "Blind".

I'm not too enthusiastic about frankensteinizing the graphics already present in the game for something else. Here, I'd rather have the Medusa head in a full grayscale version than the reuse of the Blind sprite, the original sprite being the most preferable for me. It starts with a reuse, then comes a second reuse, etc., it doesn't look "professional".

LeHerosInconnu avatar Oct 26 '21 12:10 LeHerosInconnu

Hi, @LeHerosInconnu. I'm almost convinced, that @cxong meant, that icon will look similar to "Blind" icon ( just kind of someone's head ), but would be completely newly created. Anyway, we're struggling for professional approach, but without any attempts, how could we create future expansion? Just give him a chance. ;)

Branikolog avatar Oct 26 '21 12:10 Branikolog

Hi @LeHerosInconnu , @Branikolog and @cxong , I would insist not to use the exact blind icon as it might lead to licensing issues but I see no issues to try something new. The current icon from a perspective of a new player looks like an elemental rather than something medusa-related. It really looks like a cheap piece of art work.

ihhub avatar Oct 29 '21 16:10 ihhub

Archive.zip icons in bmp / zip image

cxong avatar Dec 01 '21 10:12 cxong

Here is the beginning of something.

stoned1 stoned2 stoned3 stoned4 stoned5 stoned6

I don"t like where it's going, too much "realistic". My idea will be to make a char a bit like theses 3 spells: image black silhouette with "stonisation" ongoing.

Special Legs spell: spellH2_legs

I'll keep this page on my desktop, will come back when I have more free time to draw seriously. 😁

1GodRage avatar Sep 15 '22 19:09 1GodRage

Hi @1GodRage , so-called "stone" effect must be in contrast with black image. Also you can try to apply such effect from bottom to top like covering legs only (see Slow spell).

ihhub avatar Sep 16 '22 01:09 ihhub

Special Legs spell: spellH2_legs

This somehow reminds me about Mario leaving his suit...

ihhub avatar Sep 16 '22 01:09 ihhub

I'm quite happy with this one: stoned8 (stoned8.png)

Zoomed with Book background: image What do you think? ^^

But while doing it, I thought that the "stoning" effect should come from the eye or from the heart... because if it's only medusa-related, then, stoning from the eye could be more meaningful. But, it's the fear that stone people, so maybe the heart is more logical. So, I didn't make it coming from the ground.

Here is some images I made while working on it. I obviously started with the original "slow" image. snowboard-stop snowboard-stop paused paused stoned7 stoned7

1GodRage avatar Sep 17 '22 17:09 1GodRage

Hi @1GodRage , as @ihhub mentioned:

I would insist not to use the exact blind icon as it might lead to licensing issues but I see no issues to try something new.[...]

we can't make the new icon by editing an original Heroes 2 one and share this with fheroes2, since that would amount to copyright infringement. I hope this doesn't put you off doing this since you're really good, but this is just something we have to be very careful about.

zenseii avatar Sep 17 '22 18:09 zenseii

Thanks for the reminder, sorry I totally forgot! ^^' So I kept what I made, and deleted what was part of original asset, then redrawn it: stoned9 stoned9 stoned9b stoned 9b (removed the ground because it has nothing to do with the ground...)

Maybe it's not "easy to recognize" enough, because of too much details. stoned10 stoned10

zoomed in: 9 9b 10 image

1GodRage avatar Sep 17 '22 21:09 1GodRage

Hi, @1GodRage ! Really impressive. I like the concept of making icon similar to slow/haste icons. (It's not so far from the original icon). The second attempt (slow-like one) looks good. At the same time the last one has more uniqueness, which is nice - it would be more recognisable for players. I personally would prefer a bit more brighter gray pixels, as dark ones look close to black. The pose of the last picture looks kind of friendly. :) Could you, please, add some attacking/defending mood? Or some anxiety? :D

Branikolog avatar Sep 18 '22 18:09 Branikolog

Thank you :-)

I agree, the position of the last one is a bit funny. xD (kind of walking while saying "I don't know, maybe?" xD) 11 stoned11 12 changes: arm and knee stoned12 13 legs: more space between legs stoned13

I also made some others shadowmans for the fun. 😁 H2palette_work2022-09-18zoom300pa

1GodRage avatar Sep 18 '22 21:09 1GodRage

Hi, @1GodRage Heh, so much nice artwork! :) I love the most the one, where a man is holding his old favourite shirt full of holes. :) The icon is even better, but I'm still felling it's kind of static... Like a shadowman is holding a sword (he found on a sale) and was stunned accidentally (by the price he saw on it). Could you please make him showing us more action? Making a step? Attacking someone? Or being hit by someone? Here's some inspiration images, that came to my mind: Figures

Branikolog avatar Sep 19 '22 14:09 Branikolog

yeah, kind of stand by position, because ... fear is often not agressive attitude, but more a stand-by attitude. ^^ But ok, there is an "hurted" shadowman that also get stoned: stoned17 17 zoomed: image

13 14 15 16 stoned13-14-15-16zoom

because there isn't that much colors (black and orange border), and a smaller size than "usual creatures", complex positions can be difficult to understand. For me, in the haste icon, the shadowman is just an actor to whom we said "hold this sword and this shield, then run!", he doesn't have any additional attitude. So, if "stoned" is only cast by medusa, fear attitude or any action-like is fine, but if it's a spell that player can cast, maybe just stonisation is fine? We could even make a small icon of warlock statue... :p

1GodRage avatar Sep 19 '22 17:09 1GodRage

Hi @1GodRage , could you please try an idea to show stoning effect only for the lower part of the body? Per my opinion it is not obvious that this icon stands for.

But overall a really impressive work so far!

ihhub avatar Sep 20 '22 15:09 ihhub

Sorry, I meant @1GodRage :(

ihhub avatar Sep 20 '22 15:09 ihhub

stoned-17-22 stoned-17-22zoomed I think the stone is too bright...

Maybe I'm not really good (at painting bodies at least, I honestly never painted bodies before, my experience is self-taunt smileys in 12x12 pixels xD), because if I take the H3 sprite and transform it into shadowman: h3sprite But the H3 sprite is worth 20 hours of modeling in 3D (without clothes), no black and yellow sprite.

1GodRage avatar Sep 20 '22 18:09 1GodRage

Hi, @1GodRage .

So, if "stoned" is only cast by medusa, fear attitude or any action-like is fine,

It will happen as you're saying. We're not going to implement such spell available for a hero. Only as a creature special ability.

In a case there were a small splats of stone on a body more brighter looked better. But in current implementation (50% stoned) I think darker gray would be ok.

h3sprite

Actually, I like this crusader-like shadow. ) Previous shadowman has some issues with body proportions. I personally would take H3 shadowman, change his helmet for a head (probably looking down) and cover 40% of lower body with stone (up to middle of the rised thigh). But, Probably this concept looks a bit higher quality comparing to the original art. What do you think?

Branikolog avatar Sep 24 '22 18:09 Branikolog

I think that I can try things. ^^ And any comment helps, I know where to go.

I changed some pixels there and there to not be the H3 sprite (copyright issues?) the sword a bit more H2ish, the head rounded, added eyes. Adding eyes gives an allied nature, and ability to use eyes, so, not fitting with hurting. Removed eyes. Made the shield not rounded. (shield more recognizable, and not in a "head" shape) After reading again, I see I did too much stone. Reducedd amount of stone. Here it is:

stoned23-28transparent

stoned23-28zoom

Hmmmm about head direction, maybe, instead of eyes, adding a nose... 🤔

1GodRage avatar Sep 26 '22 00:09 1GodRage

Hmmmm about head direction, maybe, instead of eyes, adding a nose... 🤔

Hi @1GodRage,

I think these look great! In my opinion the numbers 27 and 28 look the best because the shape of the shield is better and the arm holding it seems more proportioned.

zenseii avatar Sep 27 '22 17:09 zenseii

I vote for number 28. If we have no big objections then we can even integrate such icon in the upcoming release.

ihhub avatar Sep 28 '22 09:09 ihhub

29: I changed a bit the stone effect of the 28 stoned27-28-29 stoned27-28-29zoom It may looks more H2ish, because I used the procedure that was used on the disturb ray icon. :-)

I will need some indications for the upload of the image.

1GodRage avatar Sep 28 '22 20:09 1GodRage

29: I changed a bit the sone effect of the 28

Great, @1GodRage ! What I like about this new one is that the smaller pixels make it look more like the person is currently turning into stone, which is better than it looking like just the legs were turned to stone.

zenseii avatar Sep 28 '22 20:09 zenseii

I will need some indications for the upload of the image.

Hi @1GodRage , you can just pass the original image in PNG or Bitmap format and I will do the rest of the work. We have to convert this image into fheroes2 image format and store it inside resurrection.h2d file which is shipped with the engine.

ihhub avatar Sep 29 '22 06:09 ihhub

Ok! :-) Here is the 29. :-) stoned29

edit: I doublechecked, the PNG image uploaded here is 100% like the one I made on my computer. ;)

1GodRage avatar Sep 29 '22 06:09 1GodRage

Hi, @1GodRage Sorry, for the late response. This icon look really much better! I love new shield and the pose itself. I'm only concerning about the wideness of the icon. Doesn't it much wider, than all original icons? @ihhub , what do you think, would there be an issue within game UI with such big icon? If so the sword could be shortened or positioned more vertically. Anyway, you've made a great job, @1GodRage ! The icon is definitely looking H2-ish. I'd also like to see the transition more spread, like in disrupting ray icon (sparse gray pixels could reach a bit higher level), but I'm not sure it'd look better to be honest.

Branikolog avatar Sep 29 '22 07:09 Branikolog

Hi @Branikolog , there is no limit for icon size. For example, FireBlast spell has icon of 52 x 40 pixels size. Mirror Image spell is 66 x 41 pixels so the proposed icon is absolutely fine by size.

ihhub avatar Sep 29 '22 07:09 ihhub