matroska-specification icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
matroska-specification copied to clipboard

add EditionDisplay to give human readable names to chapter editions

Open robUx4 opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

When there are multiple editions it should make it easier to pick one for the user.

Otherwise tags with TagEditionUID as the target might be sufficient and more versatile.

Fixes #300

robUx4 avatar May 22 '22 07:05 robUx4

Which edition name(string) should be used if there is an EditionDisplay and a Tag? Has the TagString from the SimpleTag a higher priority? Or should the Tag fully ignored if an EditionDisplay exists?

hubblec4 avatar May 22 '22 12:05 hubblec4

Which edition name(string) should be used if there is an EditionDisplay and a Tag? Has the TagString from the SimpleTag a higher priority? Or should the Tag fully ignored if an EditionDisplay exists?

I created #655 to fix this issue which also exists for other elements and needs to be handled independently from this PR.

robUx4 avatar Jul 31 '22 07:07 robUx4

Merging this as it's for Matroska v5 and won't affect the specs of Matroska v1 ot v4.

robUx4 avatar Aug 21 '22 14:08 robUx4