PyTorchZeroToAll icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PyTorchZeroToAll copied to clipboard

poor performance of diabetes prediction

Open Andy-jqa opened this issue 7 years ago • 7 comments

Why is the performance of using 07_diabetes_logistic.py to predict diabetes pretty poor?

Andy-jqa avatar Oct 12 '17 23:10 Andy-jqa

I guess it's due to the optimizer setting, since I modified the update rule to: optimizer = torch.optim.SGD(model.parameters(), lr=0.1, momentum=0.9) the loss decreases dramatically.

kopxiong avatar Oct 13 '17 12:10 kopxiong

@kopxiong It makes sense to change the hyperparameters. I've tried your suggestion, but the loss didn't drop to a satisfying level. Have you checked the y_pred of the final model?

Andy-jqa avatar Oct 13 '17 14:10 Andy-jqa

@kopxiong Any thoughts? Since the goal of these tutorials is understanding the concept, I did not pay attention to the accuracy.

hunkim avatar Oct 15 '17 11:10 hunkim

@Andy-jqa @hunkim Sorry for the late reply. I think we can improve the model's performance from the following aspects:

  1. add more layers or increase the number of nodes in each layer, since more units mean more powerful representation capability, like super(Model, self).__init__() self.l1 = torch.nn.Linear(8, 32) #(8, 6) self.l2 = torch.nn.Linear(32, 16) #(6, 4) self.l3 = torch.nn.Linear(16, 1) #(4, 1)
  2. use Adam optimizer to RMSProp instead of SGD
  3. use more epochs for training (like 2000 or more)
  4. sigmoid activation function maybe not good, try ReLU or LeakyReLU (I tried ReLU, but didn't work)

maybe we also should add some regularization terms to avoid overfitting.

kopxiong avatar Oct 18 '17 10:10 kopxiong

set lr = 8 and epoch i set to 10000 got around 2% error

akramsystems avatar Jun 18 '18 22:06 akramsystems

also made more nodes in the hidden layer so i set my layers to torch.nn.Linear(8, 30) torch.nn.Linear(30, 10) torch.nn.Linear(10, 1)

akramsystems avatar Jun 18 '18 23:06 akramsystems

I can not get loss below than 0.6 Any ideas?

file.zip

elcolie avatar Dec 07 '18 04:12 elcolie