hpc-shell icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
hpc-shell copied to clipboard

Drop this lesson and rely on Carpentries Shell lesson

Open ocaisa opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

We've discussed in a recent coordination meeting dropping the HPC shell and instead having the Carpentries shell lesson as a prerequisite for the HPC intro lesson. Looking quickly at the lesson, there is really only one episodes in the lesson that should be fully integrated into the HPC intro (and even this already has some overlap):

There may be some other nice points but the majority of things are actually already touched in HPC intro.

ocaisa avatar Jul 30 '21 09:07 ocaisa

One thing about adding that section is that (at least in my experience) JupyterHub interfaces are becoming increasingly common and are very powerful. It might be worth adding this option for getting a remote shell.

ocaisa avatar Jul 30 '21 09:07 ocaisa

They are becoming common. Lesson should accommodate this, but not require use of Jupyter as it is also resource intensive, ssh works well in a wide variety of situations, though takes more time to setup.

bkmgit avatar Jul 30 '21 09:07 bkmgit

Yes, totally agree, I mean it as an alternative connection option. If we bring that episode into HPC intro, I think we could extract part of it ("Logging onto the system") as a snippet , the actual mechanism for connecting is likely to vary a lot site-to-site and a snippet might be the easiest way for people to integrate their custom information.

ocaisa avatar Jul 30 '21 10:07 ocaisa