intents icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
intents copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon home-assistant

[CS] Problematic sentence in HassGetState

Open jose1711 opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Toto mi velmi nedava zmysel.

https://github.com/home-assistant/intents/blob/d074a88160ae1f29297cf2dded2344277a980fd5/sentences/cs/binary_sensor_HassGetState.yaml#L559

Jednak, preco by niekto nastavoval device class pre okna a dvere na opening (ked existuju dedikovane triedy door a window) - trieda opening podla mna bude urcena skor na nejake male poklopy. A tiez pri otazke "kolik dveri je otevreno" dostanem sucet poctu okien a dveri.

jose1711 avatar Mar 19 '25 10:03 jose1711

@halecivo @schizza

jose1711 avatar Mar 24 '25 09:03 jose1711

Dalsi problem je, ze okna mozu byt v domene cover (ak ich zvladne otvorit/zatvorit HA), ale aj binary_sensor (lacny hall senzor, ktore len snima, ci je okno privrete). To potom prinasa dalsie problemy (state je iny pri bin. senzoroch a iny pri coveroch) a cele sa to velmi nepekne komplikuje, vid moj experiment v https://github.com/jose1711/intents/blob/fb059f95abcebdff6317d77525018df002ece29b/responses/sk/HassGetState.yaml#L58-L83.

No a clovek nakoniec pride na to, ze takato funkcia vlastne ani nie je podporovana (#3110).

jose1711 avatar Mar 24 '25 22:03 jose1711