`clear_notification` message will not update badge value over cellular (outside local push?)

[jamieshaw]

iOS device model, version and app version Model Name: iPhone 15 Pro Max Software Version: iOS 17.1.1 App version: 2023.7 (2023.471)

Home Assistant Core Version Home Assistant Core 2023.10.5 (Frontend 20231005)

Describe the bug When pushing a badge value as part of a clear_notification message, if connected to Wi-Fi and using local push, the notification is dismissed and the badge value updated. When connected to cellular, the notification is cleared but the badge value remains unchanged (regardless if 0 or above).

To Reproduce

service: notify.jamie
data:
    title: 'Home Assistant'
    message: 'clear_notification'
    data:
        push:
            badge: 99

Expected behavior Consistent behaviour either setting the value or not — preferably, clear_notification will allow badge updates silently in the background. (I'm aware of delete_alert, which is similar, but different. It does not clear the notification unless setting the badge to 0 — clearing all notifications).

Screenshots https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/5qb47a3xjjfwfdma4cnke/home_assistant_notification_bug.MP4?rlkey=h2lcwj63invrub7jmktlt3jzs&dl=0 (Video showing push over Wi-Fi, then failing over cellular, and the successfully back on Wi-Fi)

Additional context In the above video notify.jamie is a group notifier that links 3 mobile_app notifiers.

[jamieshaw]

So as of Home Assistant Companion (for iOS) 2023.12.1 (2023.508), this appears to have been resolved. I can no longer get badges of any value to display regardless of connection type.

Unfortunately, not the desired outcome of allowing badging of clear_notification messages, but consistent now, nonetheless.

[jamieshaw]

I take it back — having some weird notification issues where dynamic actions where not populating — restarting the phone fixed dynamic actions but reintroduced the same bug here the badge value is not updated over cellular for clear_notification.

[lesgrebe]

+1 for me - using clear_notification long time to clear messages which a not usable any more, for example if I come home I perform an actionable notification to unlock my door via my appe watch but if Im unlocking my door manual I clear this message because its not useful any more. clear_notification now only works if Im in my home network, not over cellular as mentioned in the comment above.

iPhone 13 Pro (iOS 17.3.1) Home Assistant Companion-App 2024.1 (2024.535)

Hardware: Raspberry Pi 4 8GB

Home Assistant: Core 2024.2.1 Supervisor 2024.01.1 Operating System 11.5 Frontend 20240207.1