RadialChartImageGenerator icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
RadialChartImageGenerator copied to clipboard

Watch App Rejected because of using the radial chart interface

Open Melmer opened this issue 9 years ago • 4 comments

Because we like the interface of the radial chart and of course this tool for creating the images, we decided to use it in a production app (the triple arc variant). But.. after app submission and reviewing from Apple our App is Rejected because of:

8.3 - Apps that appear confusingly similar to an existing Apple product, interface, or advertising theme will be rejected

8.3 Details

Your app contains features that mimic the Activity app interface or behavior.

So be awared if you want to use this style in a WatchKit App.

Melmer avatar Apr 08 '16 07:04 Melmer

Please provide a short description of your app's functionality so we don't fall into the same trap.

Thanks

DataZombies avatar Apr 08 '16 12:04 DataZombies

I guess they don't want other apps to use the triple arc. @Melmer did you guys use different colors and arc widths for the arcs? Does your triple arc look too similar to the Activity app?

hmaidasani avatar Apr 09 '16 17:04 hmaidasani

We used the rings to shows some statistics. Like counting objects in a range of your current location. It has 6 screens. The second screen of the app has the triple arc and the third till fifth screens has a single circle (don't know if we also need to remove the single arc screens).

The second screen of our app look likes this:

screenshot

We used most of the default settings of the configurator.

Melmer avatar Apr 11 '16 08:04 Melmer

Try making the arcs thinner. This looks very similar to the activity app's arcs so I can see their concern.

image

You might want to play around with it.

hmaidasani avatar Apr 11 '16 17:04 hmaidasani