Hidde de Vries

+1

As a developer, I agree with @aardrian's point that reusing existing roles would be ideal for authors,. Knowing when to use which type (and which browsers/AT they work in) is...

Agree re `closeon`, not very keen on `closers` or `closes`, they seem fairly vague and therefore not intuitive. I like `closetrigger`, agreed with Brian it's accurate, and it's clear what...

Another accessibility benefit of standardised callouts/alerts/admonitions could be (the potential of) personalisation, for cognitive disabilities, and more useful rendering in reader modes.

That sounds like you're reducing accessibility to ARIA mappings? Even if those are non existent, distinctions can be helpful beyond AT, including for personalisation, COGA and reader modes, which can...

Anne said: > The benefits have to be concrete, not speculative, and cannot depend on as-of-yet unrealized downstream inventions. ok Adrian said: > Otherwise, can you identify how you think...

Like @VicGUTT , I find ‘temporary’ easier to understand than ‘transitory’ and would also need to look up and therefore be against ‘transient’ and ‘ancillary’ (all as non native speaker)....

+1 to Keith, it makes sense to me to say “hint” is a broader category than tooltip. **Tooltip**, in [Tantek's 2000 suggestion](https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2000Apr/0014.html), [Lea's 2009 proposal](https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-style/2009Apr/0225.html) and [the 2023 discussion](https://github.com/w3c/csswg-drafts/issues/8930), continues...

As we resolved on applying `:open` to `` (to which `:close` was added) in https://github.com/openui/open-ui/issues/547 … would it make sense (and technically possible?) to have `:open` apply to all popup...

Fwiw, in my talks (eg search “light dismiss” in [this slidedeck](https://talks.hiddedevries.nl/Jl79qc/slides)) and articles (eg [this one](https://hidde.blog/dialog-modal-popover-differences/)) about popover I've been explaining _light dismiss_ (dismissed by some heuristic) as the opposite...