HIPs icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
HIPs copied to clipboard

Define tracks and statuses, apply to existing BIPs

Open pinheadmz opened this issue 4 years ago • 2 comments

I think we should define "informational" vs "standards" tracks similar to this: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0002.mediawiki#bip-types and then maybe re-evaluate the existing HIPs. I think all the existing HIPs are actually informational because they do not apply do layer-1 blockchain consensus and "implementers are free to ignore them."

We should probably also define statuses like this: https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0002.mediawiki#BIP_status_field and I think all HIPs so far submitted are technically "final" -- and I think at this stage we can probably open PRs with that status.

pinheadmz avatar Jun 17 '21 15:06 pinheadmz

"implementers are free to ignore them" is a super important piece of information to communicate in a HIP, imho. Should be baked into the structure, for sure.

pbkhrv avatar Jun 18 '21 16:06 pbkhrv

Another thing to update is the track name. HIP-1 and HIP-4 are in "Standards Track", whereas others are in "Standards".

Even the website separates them in filters: http://hsd-dev.org/HIPs/proposals/

image

rithvikvibhu avatar Mar 30 '22 17:03 rithvikvibhu