Hans Moritz Günther

Well, as the author of the original code and the author of #13334 you might think that I knew what `S_max` should be. I can tell you why I put...

We should backport.

Since I don't review many PRs, I don't know what I need tp do about that though. Set the backport label?

I think pushing this to 7.0 is going too far. See https://github.com/astropy/astropy/pull/15735#discussion_r1427881233 This was always intended to work -in my view that fact that it did not is a bug...

I agree with @bsipocz : AAS journals should fix they way tables are stored. Personally, I would prefer to have all suitable AAS journal tables go to VizieE automatically, in...

Like #15774 this sounds like space-bar heating: https://xkcd.com/1172/. I don't think we have to backport, but I suggest a 6.1 milestone. We also don't have to do the extra work...

Is there any chance that ApJ will ever host the datatables at a persistent URLs? E.g. for the example in this thread, today I get https://content.cld.iop.org/journals/0004-637X/933/2/180/revision2/apjac743ft2_mrt.txt?Expires=1703097468&Signature=omUFGLoQBR1fj-d09swd7LYqfp3VQOv~OtPd45seSnr7SKXUARM2Xl8nXGLAtii8gDeZLSx5Q3Jx1nwhVwQpflD93D7g2vIiUkWaDZL2y0b2IfmkTQEx9DelchOeIb6eoxuKoDyqiBwMySk9Gqlt5F7dnhV0F29bthF7qPc7N8RBtysLdo4yNisKhpuQZ5mX-wt8-gjDhu01k57Jcn92Y2hi5WZ~ilqDykrnxWasxAaDQpocFeVa~WmFocEX9yYM1EF4Xnbs9c6bG6UBZnoP9zoPdYLR7tW4rKH2MYMn5sUpV6wCc1VgKNG2pt9xiAFIPKF6-xIzA8~c1E-dsjKgXQ__&Key-Pair-Id=KL1D8TIY3N7T8 but I know that...

I'm not sure I want to get this into astropy on the "bugfix" timescale because then we have to bugfix it every time that some publisher changes their DOM. I...

You would put that file into a git repro and curate it that way. Not ideal - but as we see downloading it form ApJ is also not a reproducible...

To, me this is more akin to "download table from Vizier", which currently is under astroquery, so that's where, as a user, I would expect this.