obsidian-kindle-plugin icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
obsidian-kindle-plugin copied to clipboard

Notes without highlight

Open adnanvaldes opened this issue 4 years ago • 4 comments

I just wanted to say this is a great plugin! I discovered it recently and it's been a game changer.

I wasn't sure whether to tag this as a bug or as a feature request, so please change the label if there's a more appropriate one.

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. When importing My Clippings.txt, all my highlights and any note associated with those highlights are imported correctly. However, notes that are not associated with a highlight fail to show up in Obsidian.

Describe the solution you'd like Would it be possible to import these notes, even if not associated with a highlight area?

Additional context

obsidian-kindle

You can see in the image above that all the notes that were highlighted imported correctly. When I simply add a note without an associated highlight, nothing shows up. Here's the relevant part of My Clippings.txt:

obsidian-kindle-clippings

Again, thank you so much!

EDIT: Here is My Clippings.txt

adnanvaldes avatar Feb 03 '22 07:02 adnanvaldes

Thanks for contributing to this project and raising your first issue.

Can I ask a couple of clarifying questions:

  1. How do you even add a note that does not reference a highlight using a Kindle?
  2. What are some of the use cases that someone would need to add a note that is not related to a highlight?

hadynz avatar Feb 03 '22 09:02 hadynz

Thanks for the prompt reply!

On the Kindle I simply press "add note" without having selected a highlight and it produces what, on the screen, looks like a reference to a footnote. This shows up in My Clippings.txt as a Note, instead of a Highlight.

I use this to write down references after longer paragraphs that expose a specific idea. For example, let's say there's a long paragraph discussing an idea that reminds me of another book. Rather than highlight an entire paragraph, I like to add a note at the beginning of the paragraph that simply refers me to another text.

I suppose the paper equivalent to this would be when you read a book and annotate the margin with cf..

adnanvaldes avatar Feb 03 '22 19:02 adnanvaldes

And where would you ideally see these "orphaned notes" be presented in your Obsidian file?. Inside the Kindle paradigm your notes are associated to a given page. But in Obsidian you are not going to have the text for that page available there.

hadynz avatar Feb 03 '22 19:02 hadynz

On the same file for a particular book. Here's an example of what I envision: notes

I realise the location reference doesn't work in Obsidian, but having these references allows me to build a graph, if you will, of references that I see in the book. Having the location allows me to access that position on the kindle using the Go to location function.

Now, I don't know how difficult doing something like this would be - if it's too much work, I can always work around it by highlighting the first word or sentence of a paragraph or something.

adnanvaldes avatar Feb 03 '22 19:02 adnanvaldes