OnBoard icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OnBoard copied to clipboard

Anirudh's Heart LED

Open anirudh12032008 opened this issue 1 year ago • 14 comments

Submission Checklist:

  • [x] I am a current high school, middle school, or home schooled student.
  • [x] I have joined the #electronics channel on Slack
  • [x] I made this board from scratch, even if I followed a tutorial
  • [x] I have followed the directions in README.md
    • [x] Created a folder under onboard/projects
    • [x] Filled out TEMPLATE.md as README.md inside your project folder
    • [x] Uploaded gerber.zip and schematic.pdf inside your project folder
    • [x] Created a folder called src and uploaded design files
    • [x] Uploaded screenshot of PCB order called cart.png with all costs included
    • [x] I am ordering the smallest batch size (ie. JLCPCB's smallest order is for 5 boards)
    • [x] If outside the US I've checked that I can afford the customs charges in my country (which isn't covered by the grant)

[^1]: Projects from a tutorial are 100% fine! We just want to ask so we can count how people are using tutorials.

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 08 '24 08:08 anirudh12032008

Hi, I'm Orpheus Leap! Here to help you review your PR.

projects/Anirudh's Heart LED:

Required files

README.md A description of your project
cart.png cart.png
gerber.zip
schematic.pdf Manually check schematic.pdf
Source files - EasyEDA Found both PCB and SCH files

You can view a render of your board over on gerber.zip/2d!

Happy OnBoarding! This bot is a simpler helper for common submission types. If there's an error with this, please point it out and someone from the OnBoard team will look at it manually.

prophetorpheus avatar Aug 08 '24 08:08 prophetorpheus

@blazecoding2009 actually I have used net labels there so all the leds are connected to the 555 , I would be really grateful if you could review the PCB once as this is my first time and I don't know wheather it's correct or not I posted it in #electronics also but no one responded there

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 08 '24 12:08 anirudh12032008

@blazecoding2009 actually I have used net labels there so all the leds are connected to the 555 , I would be really grateful if you could review the PCB once as this is my first time and I don't know wheather it's correct or not I posted it in #electronics also but no one responded there

In the schematic, I don't see it connected to VCC/3.3v

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 08 '24 13:08 blazecoding2009

@blazecoding2009 actually I have used net labels there so all the leds are connected to the 555 , I would be really grateful if you could review the PCB once as this is my first time and I don't know wheather it's correct or not I posted it in #electronics also but no one responded there

In the schematic, I don't see it connected to VCC/3.3v

But they are connected to the out pin(3) of the NE555P doesn't that supplies the current to it? Also please refer to the PCB also once 🙏

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 09 '24 02:08 anirudh12032008

It does but you need a positive and negative connection to the LEDS

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 09 '24 02:08 blazecoding2009

@LimesKey would you mind double checking for me if I'm correct here?

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 09 '24 02:08 blazecoding2009

Looks okay in the Gerber view but the schematic is wrong like what @blazecoding2009 said. Can I ask why your LEDs are THT and so large? I think your PCB should work but some of the design decisions you did are interesting.

LimesKey avatar Aug 09 '24 03:08 LimesKey

Also that, smd would be a better option and would look a bit better in my opinion. Tht usually Is also more pricey for PCBA

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 09 '24 04:08 blazecoding2009

Looks okay in the Gerber view but the schematic is wrong like what @blazecoding2009 said. Can I ask why your LEDs are THT and so large? I think your PCB should work but some of the design decisions you did are interesting.

This was really my first time creating a full PCB design so I also don't know what I did but I just did it I selected THT because with the SMT I was facing issue with the bottom copper layer 🥲 Please share your thoughts and suggestions so that I could incorporate them. For the LED connection I wanted to connect all the leds one end to the out (3) so I searched how can I do it and then choice net labels, if there's something I need to change in it please let me know.

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 09 '24 04:08 anirudh12032008

Also that, smd would be a better option and would look a bit better in my opinion. Tht usually Is also more pricey for PCBA

I was facing problem with the back layer and when I switched it worked pretty well that's why I choice it, if its possible with smt could you please share any tutorial or project with it. Then I would change it to SMT

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 09 '24 04:08 anirudh12032008

SMD is the same as THT, just want to say that it's okay to have positive and negative on the same layer

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 09 '24 15:08 blazecoding2009

SMD is the same as THT, just want to say that it's okay to have positive and negative on the same layer

But while creating the routes they were contradicting. I'll try once again today with SMT 👍

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 10 '24 02:08 anirudh12032008

SMD is the same as THT, just want to say that it's okay to have positive and negative on the same layer

But while creating the routes they were contradicting. I'll try once again today with SMT 👍

Try using vias! You should seen an optoin

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 10 '24 02:08 blazecoding2009

SMD is the same as THT, just want to say that it's okay to have positive and negative on the same layer

But while creating the routes they were contradicting. I'll try once again today with SMT 👍

Try using vias! You should seen an optoin

Thank you I'm currently a bit busy due to some assignments but I'll do it soon 👍

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 11 '24 12:08 anirudh12032008

Hi, if you need any assistance, please don't hesitate to ask here or in #electronics on Slack. This pull request is being marked as 'Stalled' for now and will be closed in 3 days if there is no activity.

github-actions[bot] avatar Aug 19 '24 01:08 github-actions[bot]

@blazecoding2009 Could you please help me out by confirming if everything is right this is my schematic so that I could move on to the pcb. Here's a 3d img also on the pcb, looking forward to your feedbacks. 3d Schematic_heart_sim_2024-08-19 (1)

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 19 '24 10:08 anirudh12032008

What's that huge thing in the top left?

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 19 '24 10:08 blazecoding2009

What's that huge thing in the top left?

its a 1k resistor Heres a rough pcb view PCB_PCB_heart_sim_2024-08-19 (4)

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 19 '24 10:08 anirudh12032008

I was talking about this: image

that is a resistor, that is HUGEEEE. use a smaller footprint one

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 19 '24 10:08 blazecoding2009

I was talking about this: image

that is a resistor, that is HUGEEEE. use a smaller footprint one

Done 3d

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 19 '24 10:08 anirudh12032008

Can you update the cart.png?

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 19 '24 11:08 blazecoding2009

Hey @anirudh12032008

Good luck! I've just sent your grant

Thank you could you please review the circuit once that it would be working? Please

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 19 '24 11:08 anirudh12032008

You're good

blazecoding2009 avatar Aug 19 '24 11:08 blazecoding2009

You're good

I have uploaded all the new files and also placed the order, Thank you ♥ Should I create another PR for that?

anirudh12032008 avatar Aug 19 '24 14:08 anirudh12032008