/resize aspect ratio is not being maintained

[foobargeez]

I have an image with 1529x2500 dimensions and I am calling imaginary as follows:

https://<imaginary host>/resize?file=test/test.jpg&width=960&stripmeta=true&quality=70

The output image has 960x2500 dimensions and I am expecting the output image dimensions to be 960x1570. Any idea how to make imaginary honor the aspect ratio?

Thanks!

[foobargeez]

BTW, if imaginary doesn't (want to) honor the aspect ratio, I can pass the height too (which is what I currently do to workaround) but the doc says, imaginary takes aspect ratio into account, so just making sure I understand what to expect.

[Dynom]

Imaginary should actually respect the aspect-ratio, but this part is a tad bit confusing. Try specifying the nocrop=true parameter and omit the height.

This works for me:

http://localhost:9000/resize?width=400&nocrop=true&stripmeta=true&quality=70&url=https%3A%2F%2Fimages.unsplash.com%2Fphoto-1546662654-5029c0524efa%3Fixlib%3Drb-1.2.1%26ixid%3DeyJhcHBfaWQiOjEyMDd9%26auto%3Dformat%26fit%3Dcrop%26w%3D1834%26q%3D80

P.s. Sorry for closing the issue, I fat-fingered it.

[foobargeez]

Specifying nocrop=true is respecting the aspect ratio. This workaround works for me (unless this is default behavior in which case, we should clarify in the doc).

[Dynom]

I agree it is and I think it can even be considered a bug, but we need to dive into that first. With image manipulation things aren't always that simple :-)