Transportr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Transportr copied to clipboard

Save selected means of transport per network provider

Open ghost opened this issue 7 years ago • 6 comments

Describe the bug When I set the which "Verkehrsmittel" (transport? e. g. bus, train) I want to use and change the region, the next time the setting is every "Verkehrsmittel" again. The same with the option "via".

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. choose a region and some means of transport (NOT every in the list)
  2. change to another region
  3. change back to the region chosen before
  4. the selection have been gone

Expected behavior Save the transport selection for every region as before version 2

Versions (please complete the following information):

  • Transportr Version: 2.0.1
  • Device: Sony Xperia
  • Android Version: 5.0

ghost avatar Jul 26 '18 13:07 ghost

Thanks for the proposal. This could easily be implemented as it was in version 1.

The only issue I see with it is that the selected means of transport are more hidden now, so people might get strange or no connections and forget that they had limited the possible options.

Maybe this could be solved by adding a notice to the "No connections found" message. However, people usually don't read those. Also, this would not help when some but strange connections are found.

grote avatar Jul 26 '18 13:07 grote

Or show the transport as before.

ghost avatar Jul 26 '18 13:07 ghost

Otherwise put an enry in settings to enable saving the means of transport by provider. Users who are using the app more carefully are likely to use settings for customization.

By the way, using German "DB" as single provider doesn't let me save the means of transport at all. For every new search I have to set the means of transport again, without closing the app.

Teansportr version: 2.0.1 and 2.0.2 OnePlus 5t Android 8.1.0

charliesz avatar Aug 03 '18 10:08 charliesz

Hi, I'd like to add a comment on this. I think it would be great if the means of transport could be saved for each favorite trip.

For example I take the bus in the morning. I use the app to check which bus number arrives first at my bus stop. I don't really want to see solutions that use trains etc but right now I have to edit that manually every time. On the other hand, on my way to the gym I need a bus + a subway so I need to manually select only those 2. Both these trips are saved as favorite but I have to manually check/uncheck the means of transport every time for each of them.

I think it would be great if each favorite trip could also have its own mean of transport preference. Thank you.

francescosoave avatar Oct 17 '19 15:10 francescosoave

This is a different feature request. This ticket is about saving means of transport per network and not per saved trip.

grote avatar Oct 17 '19 16:10 grote

@grote apologise I misunderstood the current topic. I will re-add it as new feature request. Thank you

francescosoave avatar Oct 17 '19 18:10 francescosoave