Support for RAW files?

[lrq3000]

The app is amazing, but it seems RAW images aren't supported. Is this planned in the future by any chance?

[gregordr]

Some raw types are already supported, however as you can see at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raw_image_format#Raw_filename_extensions_and_respective_camera_manufacturers_or_standard there are lots of different versions of it. Can you tell me which one is not working for you, and ideally also what error message is being logged on the backend?

[lrq3000]

Hello, thank you very much for your fast reply!

I didn't self-host yet, I just tried to upload free CR2 images from this website into the ImageStore demo, and I got an error about the incorrect filetype, specifying that only jpg, jfif, png, etc. images are supported.

So is the support for raw files just an option I can toggle when I self-host? I didn't find any mention in the readme so that's why I also thought raw images were not supported, it would be awesome if they are! :D

[lrq3000]

I just tried with my self-hosted instance, and here is the error I get:

On the website:

The following errors occured: Unknown error happened and logged in tag Pao Macasu2 (2).CR2

In the console 's log:

backend_1 | Error: Input file has corrupt header: source input: Old-style JPEG compression support is not configured backend_1 | source input: Old-style JPEG compression support is not configured backend_1 | source input: Old-style JPEG compression support is not configured backend_1 | source input: Old-style JPEG compression support is not configured backend_1 | source input: Old-style JPEG compression support is not configured backend_1 | tiff2vips: subsampled images not supported backend_1 |

[gregordr]

Thanks! I made an issue on libvips about that, maybe if I give them the image that causes it they can add support for it. Unfortunately all alternatives that do support CR2 are quite slow, so I'm not sure what the best solution would be if libvips won't add support for this kind of RAW file.

https://github.com/libvips/libvips/issues/2435

[gregordr]

Looks like they won't fix this (And I understand them).

Also, there is the issue that browsers don't work with all kinds of RAW files. As such, even if I fixed the issue above, the file couldn't be viewed, only downloaded. Converting it into a JPG before processing/storing it would be possible, but I feel like the user might be thinking that their file will stay a RAW file and try to retrieve it as one at a later point, so this solution is also not ideal.

I'm not really sure what the best course of action is here unfortunately. However, at least files with the .raw extension seem to work fine.