addons-source icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
addons-source copied to clipboard

Update WWII draft registration fields

Open Jmuccigr opened this issue 4 years ago • 6 comments

added missing fields & corrected a few others.

Jmuccigr avatar Apr 15 '20 22:04 Jmuccigr

This Form need a complete re-wright. When I created this form I was under the impression that there was only 1 card. There were 6 cards. The form need to be rewritten in a nondestructive manure.

Caulley avatar Jun 10 '22 18:06 Caulley

A revised version of the form is at /World%20War%20II%20Draft%20Registration%20Card. If someone/anyone/everyone could take a look at it and make suggestions to improve it would be helpful.

Caulley avatar Jul 25 '22 14:07 Caulley

A revised version of the form is at /World%20War%20II%20Draft%20Registration%20Card. If someone/anyone/everyone could take a look at it and make suggestions to improve it would be helpful.

@Caulley Could you provide a full link to the form? Thanks. [Update] Perhaps you're referring to the form that contains the changes in this PR? i.e. the form starting at line 7815?

hgohel avatar Jul 28 '24 16:07 hgohel

Link to the form https://github.com/Caulley/Gramps-form_us/blob/main/World%20War%20II%20Draft%20Registration%20Card#L1

Caulley avatar Jul 30 '24 09:07 Caulley

I am confused by this change.

First, it is against master branch. It should be against gramps52.

Second, the differences in the PR includes one field Place of employment or business (Address), so breaks existing forms. BUT this change is not consistent with gramps52 branch. gramps52 has the (Address) portion of the field name.

Third, when I use the form provided in the previous Comment, it appears to not break existing form entries. So that specific form change seems okay.

What I see is some additional fields (citizenship, occupation, ...) . I don't have any real examples using these new fields, so I cannot confirm that the update matches all of the WW2 DRC forms. All of my examples use the simple form that is in the original Form layout.

I think this PR needs to be closed and reopened against gramps52 and use the form_us.xml which would include the revised WW2DRC portion. Then we can test it for merging.

GaryGriffin avatar Jul 30 '24 17:07 GaryGriffin

Examples of the draft cards can be found here - https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1h2h23yhgT6V1Do6vqcGMqr2FvcoA0KA7?usp=drive_link

Caulley avatar Jul 30 '24 19:07 Caulley