helm-charts icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
helm-charts copied to clipboard

[Mimir] Add a "simple-scalable" version of helm chart

Open kszlachcikowski-locon opened this issue 3 years ago • 4 comments

Similar to Loki deployment charts add a "simple-scalable" option for Mimir (--target=all) where deploying in full microservices mode on K8s is too complex/unnecessary. Alternatively split only the read and write path without having each component separate.

kszlachcikowski-locon avatar Apr 07 '22 09:04 kszlachcikowski-locon

Hi, both are under discussion at Grafana, and read/write path should be coming first, but I don't have a timeline at the moment.

krajorama avatar Apr 07 '22 13:04 krajorama

Also very interested in this :-)

flokli avatar May 17 '22 10:05 flokli

That could be nice to have, to be able to run Mimir in a small platforms in a simple way, also with monolithic deployments.

interpeix avatar Jun 27 '22 21:06 interpeix

This would be great simply for the write path consolidation, as the inter-AZ networking costs between ingesters and distributors is very expensive on the write path (talking thousands of dollars) - we've had to buffer this by zone-locking the ingesters and distributors.

joshuapare avatar Aug 30 '22 16:08 joshuapare

Can't wait to have such chart :) I would be very awesome to provide a step between single monolithic and full micro services. 👍

AlexisDucastel avatar Oct 20 '22 15:10 AlexisDucastel

Would this effectively be a monolithic deployment if it was configured with just 1 replica?

gclawes avatar Dec 21 '22 01:12 gclawes

@gclawes not necessarily, as you would still need a read pod and a write pod - the goal here is to eliminate the high inter-AZ networking costs on each path, while still allowing for distributed load with separately scalable write and read needs across availability zones for fault-tolerance.

We use Mimir at Mosaic Learning, and we had some very high inter-AZ networking costs - we were essentially forced to zone lock each path with affinity rules (many thousands of dollars a month).

joshuapare avatar Dec 21 '22 01:12 joshuapare

any news about the mimir simple scalable helm chart ?

juanchovelezpro avatar Apr 19 '23 23:04 juanchovelezpro

Since the helm chart has been moved to https://github.com/grafana/mimir, probably good to log a ticket for this over there. I created https://github.com/grafana/mimir/issues/4832

rubenvw-ngdata avatar Apr 25 '23 07:04 rubenvw-ngdata