santa icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
santa copied to clipboard

santa daemon should have a mechanism to prevent being killed by users with root privileges.

Open izzh opened this issue 7 months ago • 1 comments

If I have root privileges, I can bypass the allowlist mechanism by repeatedly killing santa daemon in a loop.

#!bin/bash

while true; do
    ps aux | grep com.google.santa.daemon | grep -v grep | awk '{print $2}' | xargs kill -9
    if [ $? -eq 0 ]; then
        echo "kill santa daemon"
    fi
    sleep 0.5
done
santa@macos-13 Desktop % ./process_not_in_allowlist
### Before run the kill script
Santa

This application has been blocked from executing.

Path:       /Users/santa/Desktop/process_not_in_allowlist
Identifier: 0b742eae49b08af3858f17e95aa80afa82a18a178a671fc23256f12d58286894
Parent:     zsh (2021)

More info:
https://santa/blockables/E6C3C62D-8A40-5B56-99CA-191EACBCE8FD/0b742eae49b08af3858f17e95aa80afa82a18a178a671fc23256f12d58286894

### After run the kill script
santa@macos-13 Desktop % ./process_not_in_allowlist
malicious
^C
santa@macos-13 Desktop % ./process_not_in_allowlist
malicious
^C
santa@macos-13 Desktop % ./process_not_in_allowlist
malicious
^C
santa@macos-13 Desktop % 

I have observed other security software that cannot be killed even if I have root privileges.

santa@macos-13 Desktop % ps aux |grep falcon
root               375   5.5  0.7 36057876 228704   ??  Rs   Mon04PM 124:01.29 /Library/SystemExtensions/EA9DEA93-1AAA-4A86-9DC4-9CA95609D798/com.crowdstrike.falcon.Agent.systemextension/Contents/MacOS/com.crowdstrike.falcon.Agent
santa@macos-13 Desktop % sudo kill -9 375
Password:
kill: 375: Operation not permitted
santa@macos-13 Desktop ~ % 

Is it possible to implement a feature to control whether santa daemon can be killed through a configuration field? thanks~

izzh avatar Nov 15 '23 07:11 izzh