godotengine
Animation Tab Resizing Freezes Godot
Godot version
v4.0.beta12.official [3c9bf4bc2]
System information
Windows 10, Forward+, Intel Iris Xe Graphics
Issue description
When I resize the animation tab, there's a high chance of it freezing godot, for seemingly forever until i close godot. My project kept on freezing sometimes while resizing the animation tab. Beta 12 never crashed for me in any moment that wasn't me resizing the animation tab. It literally only happens when i'm resizing that tab, not always, but it feels like a 50/50 chance of freezing or not depending on how many seconds i'm taking to resize that tab.
Steps to reproduce
Use Forward+ and have a 3d model with animations, try to resize the animation tab for longer than 2 seconds. If it doesn't freeze godot the first time you resize that tab, try a few more times for longer than 2 seconds.
Minimal reproduction project
Can't reproduce in beta 17. Please attach a real MRP.
then that might means it was fixed in beta 17. Since i made this post using beta 12. Also i ddin't include a real mvp because in the rules, it mentions that no need to include a mvp but i can't submit without including, which is why i did that.
You could've just written "N/A". Like the text you highlighted said. And while MRP can be sometimes irrelevant, not everyone has "a 3d model with animations" ready for testing (I don't).
then that might means it was fixed in beta 17.
Comment if it's otherwise.
You could've just written "N/A". Like the text you highlighted said. And while MRP can be sometimes irrelevant, not everyone has "a 3d model with animations" ready for testing (I don't).
then that might means it was fixed in beta 17.
Comment if it's otherwise.
Just tested, and i tried resizing the tab multiple times, it didn't crash, seems fixed. In beta 12 it was so frustrating lel
it took longer than normal to crash though compared to beta 12, i had to resize it from it taking up most of the vertical screen, to it taking up little of the vertical screen constantly and eventually it froze godot, the same way that beta 12 did. Only difference is took more tries
oh also i didn't have the animation playing when i was resizing it, it was paused. just a small note and i had animation tree disabled, i only used regular animationplayer node hopefully this is enough info
In beta 17, you have to resize it from very short to very big and vice versa, like 10 times before it freezes godot, in beta 12, it would freeze after maybe 2 tries. Also not sure if it matters, but each time i resize, i stop holding the tab, then i resize again. Example: i resize from very small to very big, then i stop holding the animation tab, then i hold it again and resize from very big to very small, etc.
@Captainkittyca2 Please use the Edit button (located behind the … icon in the top-right corner of your comments) instead of multi-posting.
It was never in the milestone. No one else was able to reproduce this issue so far.
How can you know whether or not it wasn't in a milestone after it as removed? i'm still getting used to github overall
ah ok anyways, won't adding it to milestone make a developer actually test it out? Because right now it's in the middle of nowehere
So as I said in my first comment, you need to attach a real MRP, i.e. any zip with a model with animations that can be used to test the issue. I just tested with a random AnimationPlayer and it works without any problems, so this can't be reliably reproduced.
And by "No one else was able to reproduce this issue so far." I meant any user. If the issue was common or critical or whatever, there would be some duplicates or comments or at least upvotes. There is no activity here, so it's clear no other user had this problem.
it's not as easy to reproduce in beta 17 and RCs as it is in beta 12 The reason why i wanted people to test in beta 12 first is to check if i'm only having this issue because of my PC version combined with version of godot 4 or if it's entirely because of godot 4 With beta 17 and onwards, it still occurs but it's much more uncommon. So it's hard for even you to come by it. Which is why if i can confirm that even you or others can get it in beta 12 after about 3 tries maybe, then that means you can probably even get it in beta 17 and onwards even if it's more uncommon in those.
i'll make a godot 4 RC 5 or RC 6 project soon and try to recreate it and i'll send it
As there aren't any other reports for this, and there isn't a reproduction project for us to test this against, I'm going to close this report. Please try 4.0 stable and if you experience an issue, open a new report with a proper reproduction project.
Also, please keep discussions about issues on topic, and edit your messages instead of multiposting. Both of these problems makes it very hard to contributors to help you and figure out what the actual information about the problem is.
