Fil RetroPGF Feedback

[ccerv1]

(tweet)

Just cast my ballot for 47/106 projects participating in Fil RetroPGF!

Some thoughts:

• Loved seeing the Lotus Dependencies as well as other ecosystem projects building on Filecoin in the round!
• The voting portal worked well. It was easy to populate my ballot, browse projects, etc. Allocating voting points rather than tokens was nice too.
• My biggest challenge was reconciling overlapping impact claims: it's hard to attribute the impact of specific PRs or contributions within a repo to separate teams.
• There's also the challenge of evaluating software contributions alongside other forms of contribution (education, ops, etc), but that's nothing new.
• Ops were very smooth (IMHO), esp given that this was a new concept for many badgeholders. h/t to @tomhihihihihi and team for all their behind the scenes work.
• Badgeholder chat was very civil, with good debate and tradeoff discussions. From a governance perspective, this is where much of the value lies.

[ccerv1]

@carlbarrdahl would love a feature where I can get click the + button and get a modal that allows me to set my votes (instead of it just being added to the ballot with 0 votes)

[carlbarrdahl]

Thanks for the excellent feedback @ccerv1!

Good suggestion with a popover to enter the amount.