foo_discogger icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
foo_discogger copied to clipboard

VA Search blocks specific artist search

Open frogworth opened this issue 5 months ago • 5 comments

If the plugin deduces that the album being tagged is Various Artists, it does a "VA Search". Not sure if this is triggered by the presence of different artist tags, or just something like "Various" in the %album artist% tags.

As noted in #122 this can freeze foobar was it does this big search, but the other thing is that it's not possible to get the dialog box to search for a specific artist. It's stuck on VA Search. The only way to get around this is to remove the artist or album artist artist tags before calling the Discogger "Write tags..." command.

It would be good if we could enable or disable the VA Search, either in settings or right in that dialog.

frogworth avatar Aug 06 '25 06:08 frogworth

With a few more experiments, it looks like it's looking up the entered artist, but the artist results still only show VA Search.

frogworth avatar Aug 06 '25 06:08 frogworth

Yes, it is checking "VA" or "Various" prefixes in the album artist.

It would be good if we could enable or disable the VA Search, either in settings or right in that dialog.

I will try to include that in the next release, together with a fix for #122. Maybe at some point in the forthcoming weeks.

ghuDaYuYu avatar Aug 21 '25 23:08 ghuDaYuYu

Not fixed yet... But there is a new beta release in the Search by artist + release title discussion including configurable VA Search. You might find it useful as a temporary fix until the next public release.

ghuDaYuYu avatar Aug 30 '25 15:08 ghuDaYuYu

If the plugin deduces that the album being tagged is Various Artists, it does a "VA Search". Not sure if this is triggered by the presence of different artist tags, or just something like "Various" in the %album artist% tags.

The plugin also checks for multiple Artist IDs in the track selection, so the issue also relates to multiple artists' releases. It has been quite a gray area... The VA Search was very sketchy, and a big mistake to include it so prematurely. Also, as you mentioned https://github.com/ghDaYuYu/foo_discogger/issues/122, it exacerbated other pending issues. A solution is underway. Thanks for suggesting a quick fix while it is being solved,

ghuDaYuYu avatar Sep 09 '25 03:09 ghuDaYuYu

Excellent, thanks! I'm downloading the beta now.

frogworth avatar Sep 09 '25 06:09 frogworth