cursor icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
cursor copied to clipboard

Review my PRs

Open lowellbander opened this issue 2 years ago • 9 comments

I write PRs, and my colleagues review them. I build checklists for myself to ensure I'm putting high quality code up for review, but it's a shame that Cursor isn't providing a preliminary review!

I'd love for Cursor to be aware of the changes in my current PR (i.e. branch; I use Graphite fwiw) and critique my changes a bunch to minimize the chances that a colleague will find a flaw :)

I'd love to see recommendations for patterns I could have used, especially useful if Cursor can compare my PR against the existing codebase and let me know about existing patterns or functions I could have used. I'd like cursor to critique which new code paths I introduced without a corresponding test.

lowellbander avatar Sep 02 '23 15:09 lowellbander

And then ideally I'd be able to give Cursor some custom instructions to guide its reviews in the future

lowellbander avatar Sep 02 '23 16:09 lowellbander

ah, we know of this feature request and there is a 20% chance it will get tackled in this sprint!

sualehasif avatar Sep 03 '23 08:09 sualehasif

Oh great to hear!🤞

lowellbander avatar Sep 05 '23 02:09 lowellbander

Is there a way to add custom instructions to code reviews?

Mxs2019 avatar Mar 26 '24 18:03 Mxs2019

I'd love to see that. Codium has the feature, and even a Chrome extension that allows to chat with PR in Chrome directly. In VS Code/Cursor, this could happen in the GH extension that highlights changes, are any Git-aware context.

pandaiolo avatar Sep 04 '24 09:09 pandaiolo

when is the sprint ending?

akshay-nm avatar Dec 10 '24 12:12 akshay-nm

Any chance this will become a native feature or it will be done via plugins or via MCP?

albertocavalcante avatar Mar 30 '25 05:03 albertocavalcante

IIC There was a review tab, which was great, but was then killed in favor of the find bugs feature, which is super expensive for some reason, so I guess most people don't use it. We could probably use GitHub MCP and a good agent prompt... but I still think a first class AI PR review feature would be nice

pandaiolo avatar Mar 31 '25 08:03 pandaiolo

Any updates on this?

seminarian avatar Apr 24 '25 13:04 seminarian