core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
core copied to clipboard

Workfiles: Major/Minor versioning

Open tokejepsen opened this issue 7 years ago • 7 comments

Goal

Support major/minor versioning in the template.

tokejepsen avatar Aug 26 '18 15:08 tokejepsen

@tokejepsen can you give an example of how you'd like to see this work with the template?

We have {version} now. Would the other counterpart be {minor} or {revision}?

I haven't used this in production so I am looking to get some more input on how you are used to using this?

Also, does major/minor get similar "select version" control? And does it auto-increment the major or the minor? In UX-design, how would the user decide to increment which of the too?

BigRoy avatar Nov 04 '18 21:11 BigRoy

I personally haven't actually used major/minor versions. Think it was @mkolar that mentioned it as a feature.

tokejepsen avatar Nov 04 '18 23:11 tokejepsen

I've never seen this feature anywhere in production.

Are we talking about something like myfile_1.1.ma or myfile_v001_v001.ma?

mottosso avatar Nov 05 '18 08:11 mottosso

We use this all the time for workfiles.

An artist works toward v02 of a shot, but needs to version for himself within this version so his workfiles look like this

sh010_animation_v01
sh010_animation_v02_001
sh010_animation_v02_002
sh010_animation_v02_003
sh010_animation_v03_001
sh010_animation_v03_002

but we don't specify what the minor version needs to be at this point, so some artist use their initials and a number for instance, others, just numbers. Technically we use comments for this.

mkolar avatar Nov 09 '18 09:11 mkolar

Maybe the issue is actually that the comment field is being used for a variety of things. Perhaps there is a better wording for this field of the work file template?

tokejepsen avatar Nov 10 '18 01:11 tokejepsen

We have {version} now. Would the other counterpart be {minor} or {revision}?

We naturally started calling them subversion in the studio.

mkolar avatar Nov 15 '18 17:11 mkolar

@mkolar would you be able to propose/describe how you'd like your artists to be confronted with an interface for doing either an incremental save {version} and how they would do the {subversion} save.

What would feel natural for you?

BigRoy avatar Nov 16 '18 09:11 BigRoy