Probleme with translation of an article built up with content elements

[WillyRM]

Bug Report

Hello,

I have built up my news articles using "content elements". When I try to translate this article, the first content element within the article is replaced and linked to any content element on the page.

When I delete this content element, the linked content element is also deleted.

How can I solve the problem? If you need further information, please let me know.

Environment

• TYPO3 version(s): 8.7.19
• news version: 7.0.5
• Is your TYPO3 installation set up with Composer (Composer Mode): no
• OS: Windows 10

[friggingee]

Can confirm that this issue exists on T3 8.7.27, tx_news 6.3.0 in composer mode on Linux. Debugging shows that the DataHandler replaces one of the related content elements with a random ID when translating. I wasn't able to figure out yet, when and why exactly that happens but right now I'd assume that the issue is most likely related to a core issue with inline elements rather than a tx_news problem.

[friggingee]

Adding

$GLOBALS['TCA']['tx_news_domain_model_news']['columns']['content_elements']['config']['behaviour'] = [
    'localizeChildrenAtParentLocalization' => true,
];

seems to resolve the issue.

This might actually be a tx_news issue then, after all.

[mindpilot]

Same here: TYPO3 8.7.29 width tx_news 6.3.0 or tx_news 7.3.1 Adding 'localizeChildrenAtParentLocalization' => true, as suggested by @friggingee solves the problem.

[friggingee]

Seems to be closely related to https://forge.typo3.org/issues/57272.

In accordance with the discussion and conclusions from that ticket, I'd say that this is not an EXT:news bug after all because fixing this might break working workarounds in other installations. Also this core bug seems to be solved in v9.

[georgringer]

code changed a couple of times, closing issue therefore. feel free to reopen a new one if still relevant