xwing icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
xwing copied to clipboard

Epic Ships

Open atmcmurp opened this issue 9 years ago • 3 comments

Let me start by saying that I enjoy using your squad builder.

I have noticed that epic ships with multiple ship cards do not function well within your squad builder. One issue is that each card gets a modification option even though only one is allowed for the epic ship. Secondly, Ordinance Tubes bonus does not translate to both halves when selected for one side . This means that a player can not option in a missile or torpedo to one half of the ship. I understand that these are due to coding restriction. Have you considered that since the two cards for an epic ship can not be taken separately that for the purpose of your squad builder they should be treated as a singular card? By doing this you resolve both listed issues since all upgrade options will list at once and be nested together.

atmcmurp avatar Jul 09 '16 05:07 atmcmurp

Huge ships with two halves can't be treated as a single card, since you have to track which upgrade cards belong on which half of the ship (which is important for dealing suffering critical effects, and discarding upgrades when halves become crippled).

I have been thinking about how to associate ship halves together, and it keeps being more difficult each time I look at it. I'll keep thinking about it, though, as I do want to solve this problem.

geordanr avatar Jul 25 '16 17:07 geordanr

Is this issue still being developed on? This squad builder is my favorite by far but this issue keeps me from using it for Epic list building.

and-ampersand-and avatar Aug 24 '17 13:08 and-ampersand-and

I have not really looked into this. I keep hoping for an Epic FAQ update from FFG to clarify some of the modification weirdness and help with nailing down rulings, but also the code is really not amenable to supporting weird stuff like Ordnance Tubes. So I don't think support for this will be forthcoming any time soon.

If I do a rewrite of the builder engine I will keep this in mind.

geordanr avatar Aug 25 '17 18:08 geordanr