gamma-cat icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
gamma-cat copied to clipboard

Check last few tevcat / tgevcat sources

Open cdeil opened this issue 9 years ago • 12 comments

In #2 @vorugantia lists a few sources that should be checked / added to gamma-cat.

This is a reminder issue for myself to do that.

  • [x] Any tevcat id beyond 257 did not have a tevcat2 id (the URL doesn't redirect). For these sources, I left the tevcat2_id field as null.
  • [ ] tevcat id 129 is unpaired with any tgevcat source, but is SIMILAR to tevcat id 74 (which is paired).
  • [x] tevcat id 163 and 164 are unpaired, because tgevcat "combines" these two with tgevcat id 111.
  • [ ] tevcat id 261 is unpaired. One of its alternative names does appear on tgevcat id 145, but this is paired with ANOTHER tevcat source (id 149).
  • [ ] Same issue as above for both tevcat id 278 and 279 - they match up with tgevcat id 130, but that's already paired with tevcat id 143.
  • [ ] Same issue again with tevcat id 253 - it matches with tgevcat id 37, but that's already paired with tevcat id 86.
  • [ ] These are the other tevcat sources that simply do not have a tgevcat counterpart at all:
    • [ ] 88 - MilagroDiffuse
    • [ ] 174 - SNR G106.3+02.7
    • [ ] 263 - PKS 1441+25
    • [ ] 264 - S3 1227+25
    • [ ] 265 - S2 0109+22
    • [ ] 266 - PKS 1440-389
    • [ ] 267 - PKS 0625-35
    • [x] 268 - HESS J1534-571
    • [x] 269 - VER J1746-289
    • [x] 270 - HESS J1813-126
    • [x] 271 - HESS J1826-130
    • [x] 272 - HESS J1828-099
    • [x] 273 - HESS J1832-085
    • [x] 274 - HESS J1844-030
    • [x] 277 - HESS J1746-285
    • [x] 280 - HESS J1852-000

cdeil avatar Aug 31 '16 10:08 cdeil

Added HESS J1800-240A as source_id=111 in 8f379ff . Added HESS J1800-240B as source_id=156 in 60f9755 .

cdeil avatar Aug 31 '16 10:08 cdeil

The ~15 sources in tevcat that were missing from tgevcat are simply new detections from the last year or two, that haven't been included in tgevcat yet.

They should be added to gamma-cat with tgevcat_id: null I've put a task list at the top of this issue so that we can do it one by one.

cdeil avatar Aug 31 '16 13:08 cdeil

Added HESS J1852-000 as source_id=157 in c6fb71fac3f683e2834536c59ef893d424e8b866 .

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 11:09 cdeil

Any tevcat id beyond 257 did not have a tevcat2 id (the URL doesn't redirect). For these sources, I left the tevcat2_id field as null.

It looks like it's just two sources:

  • S4 0954+65 -- http://tevcat.uchicago.edu/?mode=1&showsrc=258
  • VER J2019+368 -- http://tevcat.uchicago.edu/?mode=1&showsrc=259

Higher numbers do have TeVCat 2 entry, e.g.

  • HESS J1852-000 -- http://tevcat.uchicago.edu/?mode=1&showsrc=280

So I'm marking that task as complete now. If there's no TeVCat 2 page at this time, nothing we can do about that.

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 11:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1813-126 as source_id=160 in 4eb7626

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1826-130 as source_id=161 in e2a7f63

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1534-571 as source_id=158 in c9263c2

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1746-285 as source_id=159 in 5d7d1072974f91e92d41600fc6cb148c4815bb4b

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added VER J1746-289 in comments in source_id=159 in 5d7d107 and made a separate issue for this case: #18

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1828-099 as source_id=162 in 1660dd4 .

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1832-085 as source_id=163 in 0dfcccc

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil

Added HESS J1844-030 as source_id=164 in b1a11bf

cdeil avatar Sep 08 '16 12:09 cdeil