SFDX Extension is not working for Scratch Orgs

[Schuchie]

Summary

I only can use this extension for Sandboxes. When I'm switching to an existing Scratch Org. Im not able to push/pull/depoy/retrieve any source via the context menu.

It all works for Sandboxes. I also switched between multiple Scratch Orgs (also different from Different Dev Hubs). It looks like all Scratch Orgs are affected:

Connected to a sandbox:

Connected to a scratch org:

As you can see in the scratch org-screen: the sfdx: commands are missing completely in the context menu.

Steps To Reproduce:

1. Auth a scratch org via the following: sfdx auth:sfdxurl:store -f ./[email protected] -a [email protected]
2. Set default org in the vscode-project
3. You shouldnt be able to deploy anything via the context menu
4. Try to switch to a sandbox
5. You should be able.

Expected result

I can see all options from the salesforce extension in vscode.

Actual result

I can not see all options from the salesforce extension in vscode.

Additional information

I can also see some errors in the vscode-dev-console. This error only occurs on activating your extension:

Salesforce Extension Version in VS Code:

SFDX CLI Version: 7.143.0-7049747

OS and version: macOS Big Sur 11.6

[Schuchie]

Found a closed issue without any workaround or bugfix from your site: https://github.com/forcedotcom/salesforcedx-vscode/issues/3558

Or also closed: https://github.com/forcedotcom/salesforcedx-vscode/issues/3521

[Schuchie]

Also maybe one more hint:

• The Auth-File is in a whole different folder and not in the same folder as the sfdx project. After the authentication I just set the default org in my sfdx project to the before authenticated org.

[jag-j]

@Schuchie - There is a known limitation in source tracked orgs (which includes scratch orgs and some sandbox orgs) and so we don't show "SFDX: Deploy Source to Org" and "SFDX: Retrieve Source From Org" commands for them. We are actively working on this and should have a fix out in one of the upcoming releases. Thank you!

[Schuchie]

Hey @jag-sfdc, but some of mine colleges can use this functionality on scratch orgs (based on same org shape etc.) so its looks completely random for me.

[Schuchie]

@jag-sfdc any update on that problem?

[randi274]

Hi @Schuchie to follow up on this one - this is an item we're actively working on! We have some big internal updates to roll out first, but once those are out the door we have a lot of this work ready to go. Keep an eye on your release notes over the next month for changes to the source deploy/retrieve behavior. ( #safeharbor of course 😄 )

[Schuchie]

@randi274 Thats sound pretty good. Thx for the feedback!

[Schuchie]

Any update? @randi274

[randi274]

Getting real close 🤞 those big internal updates turned out to be BIG, but those are finally almost out the door. An updated timeline would likely be after the Dreamforce dust settles.

[kevanmoothien]

Got the same issue recently and not able to resolve it. :(

[avaHitesh-github]

I'm facing the same issue :(

[kevanmoothien]

Hi @avaHitesh-github, I was able to resolve this issue by removing the sf cli and keeping only the sfdx one. Hope it helps in you case.

[Schuchie]

I still have the same problem since the creation of the issue. I dont have sf cli installed only sfdx.

@randi274 did you already published your update?

[avaHitesh-github]

@kevanmoothien I've only installed SFDX CLI but I do see a .sf folder as well and also see the SF command in bin folder of sfdx. Is it just like removing the file from the bin folder or do I need any further steps or commands to remove the SF from sfdx? Thanks!

[kevanmoothien]

I had uninstalled everything including the sf and sfdx cli complement. I also deleted the project's .sf and .sfdx folders. And then I deleted all local configurations that may exist. (On Ubuntu, it was /home/user/.sf and /home/user/.sfdx. And then install sfdx from a fresh install.

[randi274]

Hi @Schuchie thanks for the follow-up! We're actively working on this during this iteration, so those Deploy/Retrieve commands will appear against scratch orgs once that work is complete.

No ETA on it just yet, but @klewis-sfdc if you're able, can you tag this ticket once that work is ready?

[randi274]

Just to make sure we're not confusing the issue though @Schuchie - are you still finding that the Push/Pull commands are neither working through the Command Palette nor appearing in a context menu when you're working against a scratch org? That functionality is what should be working today.

[Schuchie]

@randi274 Testest two days ago, these settings were not available on a new project. Also updated the CLI and all the other stuff to the latest version. Still no diff.

sfdx-cli/7.183.1 darwin-arm64 node-v18.11.0 SF Extension package v56.14.0

[henriqueadonai]

I've this problem.