flyinghead
[V2.2] [WINDOWS] no response when using XBOX controller with DS4 controller
Please Note: This form is the minimum required information for submitting bugs.
Removing this form may lead to your issue being closed until it is completed.
Platform / OS / Hardware: Windows 11 PRO (genuine with key)
Github hash:
Hardware: INTEL 12th gen mobile + NVIDIA 3050 RTX + XBOX One S controller + dualshock 4 (both connected BT)
Description of the Issue Using flycast 2.2 public build. When using individually each controllers, they work fine and i can control all games without issues. Same happens when using 2 XBOX controllers. However, as soon as the dualshock is introduced in combination with one or both XBOX controllers, no inputs work anymore and the screen displays wrong controller names:
Case of 2 XBOX + 1 DS4:
Case of 1 XBOX and 1 DS1:
Working cases with only the 2 XBOX controllers:
And with only the DS4:
Debugging Steps Tested
-
connected all 3 controllers and noticed that 2 PS4 controllers + 1 XBOX controller appeared Tried to perform mappings for all 3 lines with all 3 physical controllers : none responded
-
close flycast and delet emu.cfg, restart with DS4 shut down Working correctly : both XBOX controllers are assigned to A and B ports and can be configured
-
close flycast and delet emu.cfg, restart with 1 DS4 and 1 XBOX controller PS4 Controller appearing twice, tried to perform mappings for all 2 lines : none responded
-
close flycast and delet emu.cfg, restart with only DS4 connected All working fine
Logs Gathered
No logs
Please try with the latest master build since SDL has been upgraded a few times since v2.2.
Downloaded last master :
Same behaviour:
Not sure the issue is with SDL, as the library supports PS4 controller since multiple versions.
Made an additional test:
With this, i am able to setup controller in port C, and it detects buttons of 2 controllers:
- the DS4 (as SDL)
- one of the 2 XBOX controllers (as dinput)
As you see :
Here i have defined up on the DS4 and down on the XBOX controller
I think the index has issues, as SDL and dinput do not share the same indexes, the joystick instance messes up the devices. 2 devices merged into 1.
The device in port A is not configurable, on any of the controllers.
Here are my device numbers: XBOX dark :
- SDL index 0
- dinput index 0
XBOX white :
- SDL index 1
- dinput index 2
DS4 :
- SDL index 2
- Dinput index 1