editorjs-text-color-plugin
editorjs-text-color-plugin copied to clipboard
Is it sensible to use deprecated <font> tag?
The markup produced by this plugin for inline font color is the <font>
tag. This feels semantically correct, but <font>
as a tag is deprecated and all official advice states that this should not be used.
While potentially unlikely due to its historic prevalence, there could be a situation in the future where it is removed from browsers. All you're doing here is adding some inline CSS. Is there a reason a <span>
element shouldn't be used instead?
Hey @chrisdeeming,
Thanks for bringing up the use of the deprecated <font>
tag in our project!
We initially chose the <font>
tag to provide a unique identifier, making it easier to pinpoint and undo color changes. We know <span>
is pretty common and might be used by other plugins on the same text, so we wanted to avoid potential conflicts.
Your reminder about the <font>
tag being deprecated is really helpful, and we're now looking into alternative solutions that might work better than using a <span>
tag.
In the meantime, we'd love to hear your thoughts and ideas, as you seem to have a ton of experience in this area. If you have any suggestions or would like to contribute by submitting a PR with an improved solution, we'd be super grateful for your input.
Hello everyone, I would like to point out an advantage of using the **<FONT>
**tag.
If I use html saved by the plugin to generate an xdoc file with PHPWord, the color of the text is recognized by Word.
If I use the span tag, the color is ignored. Considering that editorjs is a way to store text, you should consider this backward compatibility with word.
After a quick test it seems that to convert <FONT>
to <SPAN>
you also need to use color in the form of hexadecimal like this: <span style="color: #db1e1e">Lorem ipsum</span>
. Maybe converting the text created by editorJS to Word is not a common use, however I do not exclude that the same problem is present even if you convert it to text in PDF format
The font
tag feels right in this context. You avoid having to sanitize the CSS inside the HTML (which can be a pain). It's sad that they have deprecated the tag, it seems still useful in specific situations like this.