openpose-editor icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
openpose-editor copied to clipboard

[Bug] When there are no legs we get crazy results

Open shaneholloman opened this issue 2 years ago • 7 comments

See image

image

shaneholloman avatar Feb 20 '23 00:02 shaneholloman

This is so because the points not detected are placed at random coordinates. Do you have any ideas?

fkunn1326 avatar Feb 20 '23 00:02 fkunn1326

I am now looking at the original openpose to see how it is handled for images like this. So far I noticed those points were simply removed

https://github.com/CMU-Perceptual-Computing-Lab/openpose#results

shaneholloman avatar Feb 20 '23 00:02 shaneholloman

personal current workaround is to make canvas larger than image and manually pull dots "out of frame"

Rb-diff avatar Feb 20 '23 12:02 Rb-diff

Whatever https://github.com/Mikubill/sd-webui-controlnet 's openpose preprocessor does, seems to handle this case fine.

MrCheeze avatar Feb 20 '23 18:02 MrCheeze

And it stil struggles with moments when bones interlap each other. It confuses where is what. Is there a way to detect that bones are behind another bone or object?

Drakmour avatar Feb 23 '23 15:02 Drakmour

Seeing this now, but I posted a feature request to be able to delete segments: https://github.com/fkunn1326/openpose-editor/issues/62

This would address many of these issues

jwvanderbeck avatar Mar 03 '23 17:03 jwvanderbeck

Seeing this now, but I posted a feature request to be able to delete segments: #62

This would address many of these issues

I guess that just deleting bones or joints will not solve all the problems, cuz it will just try to make those bones cuz it knows they are usually there. It can try to meld the ends of deleted bones with other objects and bones. It should know that there is a bone but you can't see it, cuz it's overlapped by another bone or object.

Drakmour avatar Mar 03 '23 18:03 Drakmour