first-contributions icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
first-contributions copied to clipboard

"Can you assign this to me?"

Open buhtz opened this issue 2 weeks ago • 2 comments

I am an FOSS upstream maintainer very open to new contributors but also dealing with low-level-know-nothing-but-commit-and-star-collection wannabies.

Please add an explanation about how issue/PR assignment works and that asking "Can you assign this to me?" is not a good idea.

Maybe also add an explanation that using Mentions (with "@") are also not a good idea.

buhtz avatar Dec 08 '25 10:12 buhtz

I'd like to work on this. I'll:

  1. Research best practices for GitHub issue assignment etiquette
  2. Draft a section for CONTRIBUTING.md explaining:
    • Why "Can you assign this to me?" is problematic
    • Proper ways to show interest in an issue
    • When/why to use @mentions
  3. Submit a PR within [timeframe, e.g., 3-5 days]

It would also be helpful if you tell me if there is a specific preference for documentation location or style.

Tamujacob avatar Dec 08 '25 12:12 Tamujacob

Just from my perspective as a maintainer:

  • Proper ways to show interest in an issue

That is a good and positive approach compared to just say "don't ask it". 🤣

  • When/why to use @mentions

Just don't. Never. There is not reason to do this.

  1. Submit a PR within [timeframe, e.g., 3-5 days]

What I often experience is that contributors do not read my contribution info I have placed in several locations. Of course there is a CONTRIBUTING.md in my project. But there is also a default text when opening an issue (see template) or a PR (see tempalte) giving minimal advice. Especially my Good First Issues (examples) have an introduction text and step by step advice. They just don't read it or don't follow it.

buhtz avatar Dec 08 '25 12:12 buhtz