octo4a icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
octo4a copied to clipboard

cannot connect phone to printer

Open benj04800 opened this issue 2 years ago • 27 comments

I am using a ZTE 7 mini to connect to an Ender 5 pro the phone has USB OTG. When I attach the USB cable using the splitter it says that the printer is not connected. I think the issue is that the printer is not being automatically detected. I do not know how to manually select the correct driver which should be CH341 in the app.

benj04800 avatar Jan 25 '22 01:01 benj04800

update

I discovered that the issue is that when I have both the charging cable and the printer connected to the phone, the phone will not recognize the printer. When the charging cable is unplugged the phone will recognize the printer. How do I both charge and connect to the printer at the same time?

benj04800 avatar Jan 25 '22 23:01 benj04800

I can't connect either. How exactly are we supposed to connect? The install went great till that happened.

dangel1967 avatar Jan 26 '22 06:01 dangel1967

@benj04800 Do you have Wireless Charging on your device?

Raul-7-7 avatar Jan 29 '22 21:01 Raul-7-7

No

On Sat, Jan 29, 2022, 3:44 PM Raul-7-7 @.***> wrote:

@benj04800 https://github.com/benj04800 Do you have Wireless Charging on your device?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/feelfreelinux/octo4a/issues/145#issuecomment-1024992035, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AXPC7DFBHW2K3KR36FQ2GTLUYRNVFANCNFSM5MW6YFDQ . Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1477376905?ct=notification-email&mt=8&pt=524675 or Android https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.github.android&referrer=utm_campaign%3Dnotification-email%26utm_medium%3Demail%26utm_source%3Dgithub.

You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

dangel1967 avatar Jan 29 '22 22:01 dangel1967

i encounter the same issue with huawei and ender3 v2

Jacob12138xieyuan avatar Feb 10 '22 04:02 Jacob12138xieyuan

I have it running on my tablet. The server is running and it says the printer is connected. But when I go to octoprint in my browser it will not connect and just times out. I have switched from auto to manual and tried every listed baudrate. no luck

What am I missing?

manningcustom avatar Feb 10 '22 20:02 manningcustom

i soldered 2 wires directly to my battery which are then connected to external charging module tp4056. By adding that you technically have 2 usb connectors, one for charging and other one for OTG.

miroan81 avatar Feb 20 '22 02:02 miroan81

update

I discovered that the issue is that when I have both the charging cable and the printer connected to the phone, the phone will not recognize the printer. When the charging cable is unplugged the phone will recognize the printer. How do I both charge and connect to the printer at the same time?

I'm having the same issue with several USB C adapters and 2 recent android devices... as soon as I plug in the power adapter the serial connection is ended... I disconnect the power the serial connection is back.. very disappointing. I haven't found a solution/adapter that works.

I cannot use the ocot4a app/phone instead of an rpi.

lola66 avatar Mar 08 '22 23:03 lola66

I been using S7 Edge Samsung with wireless charging and OTG cable for months now without issue. If your phone has wireless charging, give that a shot.

Raul-7-7 avatar Mar 08 '22 23:03 Raul-7-7

I been using S7 Edge Samsung with wireless charging and OTG cable for months now without issue. If your phone has wireless charging, give that a shot.

Sadly they don't, (Umidigi Power and F1) If wireless charging is the "easy" fix, fine. But that information is missing from the main Github project page. An explanation or warning about this major hardware limitation should be included IMO. If the phone can't be charged while printing then it's not a viable solution for running octoprint for hours/days... I do like the idea or recycling my old phones, so I will look into removing the batteries and powering them directly.

lola66 avatar Mar 09 '22 17:03 lola66

I been using S7 Edge Samsung with wireless charging and OTG cable for months now without issue. If your phone has wireless charging, give that a shot.

Sadly they don't, (Umidigi Power and F1) If wireless charging is the "easy" fix, fine. But that information is missing from the main Github project page. An explanation or warning about this major hardware limitation should be included IMO. If the phone can't be charged while printing then it's not a viable solution for running octoprint for hours/days... I do like the idea or recycling my old phones, so I will look into removing the batteries and powering them directly.

You don't have to remove battery, just connect buck converter set to around 3.8-4V to battery terminals or use tp4056 charging module instead of buck converter. That way octo can run even if there's power disruption of some kind. Either option is good but buck is better in my opinion since it wont keep battery full all the time

miroan81 avatar Mar 09 '22 17:03 miroan81

I been using S7 Edge Samsung with wireless charging and OTG cable for months now without issue. If your phone has wireless charging, give that a shot.

Sadly they don't, (Umidigi Power and F1) If wireless charging is the "easy" fix, fine. But that information is missing from the main Github project page. An explanation or warning about this major hardware limitation should be included IMO. If the phone can't be charged while printing then it's not a viable solution for running octoprint for hours/days... I do like the idea or recycling my old phones, so I will look into removing the batteries and powering them directly.

I found its more a hit and miss, OTG + Charge (Y split cables) seem to work on some phones, I did try a few options on Samsung S7 but none worked, so I went the wireless direction, however, I seen many on Reddit reporting Y Split cable does charge and OTG for them. I am just grateful this project exists!!! saved me some $$$ and helps with environment.

Raul-7-7 avatar Mar 09 '22 20:03 Raul-7-7

I've had similar issue with xiaomi mi9. I'm using something like usbc dock with HDMI, ethernet etc. Solution was changing rom, MIUI to pixel experience(android 12). No more issues so far! Thanks for great software

Filo301 avatar Mar 12 '22 04:03 Filo301

Hello, I also get no connection between my Ender and my S21. The Charging is no prerequisite for the connection, right?

Best regards, Hendrik

henfri avatar Mar 13 '22 12:03 henfri

Hi, just installed octo4a on my old Galaxy S9, connected a new OTG cable and plugged in. I cannot see the printer at all. I tried going into Developer Options and setting USB mode to Android Auto but it cannot see the printer still. What am I missing?

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 10:04 nickr1957

Hi, just installed octo4a on my old Galaxy S9, connected a new OTG cable and plugged in. I cannot see the printer at all. I tried going into Developer Options and setting USB mode to Android Auto but it cannot see the printer still. What am I missing?

Your cable is probably the problem, try connecting USB flash drive and see if its visible on your phone.

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 miroan81

Yes I can see files on a SD card plugged in using the same OTG cable

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 nickr1957

When you open oct4a app, do you see your printer there in connected printers?

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 miroan81

No, I see no printers, that's why I can't conndct.

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 nickr1957

And when you connect printer to a PC, can your PC see it?

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 miroan81

It works find from a PC using Print wit USB and from a Pi running Octoprint

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 nickr1957

Thats weird, I haven't had to change anything on my mobile to be able to recognize my printer. Few times I had a problem where I had to restart or fully shut down my mobile to open usb connection, so try that if you havent already.

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 miroan81

Its weirder than that! My phone just popped up a message out of the blue asking if I wanted to allow it to bridge using UART and when I said yes to that, my printer suddenly connected. Didnt change any settings, didnt plug in the printer any differently (in fact it was plugged in for 10 mins or so already) so no idea why it suddenly asked for access...

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 nickr1957

Whether it will work next time is a question but I think I'll try a print before disconnecting and reconnecting...

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 nickr1957

Thats good to hear, anytime you had something like that just restart both mobile and printer, it happens but rarely. Im using this app for the last two months, works perfectly, I've had few week long prints with octolapse runing in backgound, it didn't fail so far. Just install arcwelder in Cura or whatever slicer you are using, it helps immensely with slow baudrate

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 13:04 miroan81

Arcwelder? Thanks, I'll take a look. Printing seems to be working, the crunch cones when I disconnect everything andctry to reconnect...

nickr1957 avatar Apr 16 '22 14:04 nickr1957

Yeah, its a plugin for slicer as well as octoprint that simplifies gcode so when printing complicated things with a lot of curves you dont get strange artifacts due to slow datarate and nozzle shutter. https://community.octoprint.org/t/noticeably-worse-quality-from-octoprint-than-from-sd-card-ender-3-v2/33797/2

miroan81 avatar Apr 16 '22 15:04 miroan81

Hi, thanks for trying octo4a!

Please try connecting an USB mouse first. If a cursor doesn't appear this means this is a problem with the OTG cable or your phone does not support OTG.

Cheers!

PS: feel free to ping me if you need this issue to be re-opened

alufers avatar Oct 07 '22 00:10 alufers

I use OTG for many other things - camera control, external keyboard, digital microscope. So I know OTG works.

Sent from Samsung Mobile on O2

-------- Original message -------- From: alufers @.> Date: 07/10/2022 01:01 (GMT+00:00) To: feelfreelinux/octo4a @.> Cc: Nick Ramsey @.>, Comment @.> Subject: Re: [feelfreelinux/octo4a] cannot connect phone to printer (Issue #145)

Hi, thanks for trying octo4a!

Please try connecting an USB mouse first. If a cursor doesn't appear this means this is a problem with the OTG cable or your phone does not support OTG.

Cheers!

PS: feel free to ping me if you need this issue to be re-opened

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/feelfreelinux/octo4a/issues/145#issuecomment-1270855630, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AYYDV4BXTBTT65J3L64LID3WB5R4HANCNFSM5MW6YFDQ. You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

nickr1957 avatar Oct 07 '22 06:10 nickr1957