facebook
Validator should not expect "public_transport=platform_edge" to be an area
Description
public_transport=platform_edge should actually always be a way, not an area / closedway.
Screenshots
Version
2.3.2
What browser are you seeing the problem on? What version are you running?
Firefox 129.0.2
The OS you're using
Windows 10
Steps to reproduce
- Navigate to a way tagged with
public_transport=platform_edge - Open Issues panel
The browser URL at the time you encountered the bug
https://rapideditor.org/edit#map=20.00/47.67683/-122.31741&id=w1272407159
The auto-detected useragent string for your browser (leave blank if you're manually filling this form out)
No response
It doesn't look like a commonly used tags, but you're right that the examples I see are all ways. It makes sense to remove this validation check. Wdyt @atiannicelli?
I don't see any documentation in the wiki for this tag. I do see railway=platform_edge which is always a way and not an area. Seems like the validation check probably should be dropped since the tag is not a defined tag in the wiki.
I don't see any documentation in the wiki for this tag. I do see railway=platform_edge which is always a way and not an area. Seems like the validation check probably should be dropped since the tag is not a defined tag in the wiki.
Documentation is here: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:public_transport%3Dplatform_edge
Weird!!! When looked for it earlier I didn't find it.
Well, in that case I am in full agreement with removing that validation or changing it to make sure that it is a way and not an area.
I checked this again and I'm not seeing this warning anymore as of Rapid v2.5.0 👍 I'm pretty sure it was fixed as a result of 7b115b87 , which makes it so that we don't raise "invalid geometry" warnings anymore if the feature doesn't match a known preset.
