Evan Bauer

@annethoul I think I recall you had some plots that pretty specifically isolate where the location should be based on the profiles vs where it is reported in the history...

> Also, kind of separate issue but linked to this one, once a "semiconvective" region (due to CPM) develops, MESA has no way to locate its boundary. Again, easy to...

@matthiasfabry, this one should be ready to go. Can you take a quick look and merge if you think it's ready?

@orlox could you give this one a quick review and merge when you're ready?

Thanks for the report! Unfortunately the documentation states that CMS is currently in an "experimental" status in terms of its implementation in MESA: https://docs.mesastar.org/en/release-r24.03.1/eos/overview.html#cms My recollection is that we were...

Does this persist if you include predictive mixing or convective premixing in your model? Without one of those options or some overshoot, it's very likely that convective boundary evolution will...

Hmmm, thanks for checking. Going back to it, it's not as easy to reproduce as I had thought. I'll look a bit closer. I think you're right that there's something...

Weird. It took me a while to come up with a good MWE because it turns out that `terminal_interval` is involved as well. Here's a very simple MWE: ``` &controls...

Well, now that I'm reading the code, it seems pretty intentionally set this way. Why? Here's where we decide if we're going to write a profile. https://github.com/MESAHub/mesa/blob/185398e6f1252d32c2497edec57ad71ecc6cd5dd/star/private/do_one_utils.f90#L1527-L1529 And here's where...

Oh, maybe the profile header information? I suppose it could be sufficient just to document this behavior in controls.defaults, but I might try to track this logic a little further...