auto-sort-bookmarks-webext icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
auto-sort-bookmarks-webext copied to clipboard

Feature request: Why does the addon need to access Firefox history?

Open sahil48 opened this issue 6 years ago • 4 comments

I can understand the other permissions, but I am not clear accessing history is needed.

sahil48 avatar Oct 30 '18 21:10 sahil48

The add-on needs to use the "history" Permission/API to sort bookmarks by the date/time of the last visit.

eric-bixby avatar Oct 31 '18 03:10 eric-bixby

I added an entry to the FAQ for this: https://github.com/eric-bixby/auto-sort-bookmarks-webext/wiki/Frequently-Asked-Questions-(FAQ)

eric-bixby avatar Nov 03 '18 21:11 eric-bixby

On one hand, I'm OK with the permissions required here for downloads and history. Technically I understand the requirements. On the other hand, I'm not comfortable at all with an addon, in general, with access to the downloads API or my history.

I really hope you will make these permissions optional, even if it has to be in a separate Lite version of this plugin. I don't want any language other than for my default browser language, so you don't Really need perms for downloads. And (I'm probably wrong) but I think History is just like any other bookmark, so that also bothers me. Perhaps you could make operations on history optional as well, going back to a plugin that does not require any extra permissions. Thanks.

TonyGravagno avatar Mar 21 '19 20:03 TonyGravagno

Yes, I'll consider making it optional.

Originally, I don't recall seeing a way of making permissions optional, but after rechecking the Mozilla docs, I see how to do it.

eric-bixby avatar Mar 22 '19 21:03 eric-bixby