flownet icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
flownet copied to clipboard

Too many observations used when history matching Norne

Open wouterjdb opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

Some time ago we removed the resampling of observations. This worked well in the Brugge case but for Norne we end up with a lot of observations as well as a lot of zero observations.

Examples:

image

image

Any comments? @anders-kiaer @olwijn @edubarrosTNO @olelod

wouterjdb avatar Oct 08 '20 14:10 wouterjdb

After some discussions here. The zeros will not have an impact. But the large number of observations might lead to ensemble collapse. The resampling as used before might solve this.

However, there is a more sophisticated way available in ERT that we could test: I got the suggestion to use: https://fmu-docs.equinor.com/docs/ert/reference/configuration/keywords.html#std-scale-correlated-obs (only accessible inside equinor - but the documentation is open, just check the github pages for ert).

wouterjdb avatar Oct 08 '20 14:10 wouterjdb

Just came a release message for ERT 2.15 where the STD_SCALE_CORRELATED_OBS workflow is said to be deprecated and that it is recommended to use the MISFIT_PREPOCESSOR instead, see https://fmu-docs.equinor.com/docs/ert/reference/workflow_jobs.html?highlight=misfit_preprocessor.

The manual doesn't mention the MISFIT_PREPROCESSOR workflow, so I'm not sure yet what exactly to use...

Update: Just realized that ERT 2.15 is in testing at the moment and is going to be released soon. Forefront of technology @anders-kiaer - as usual.

wouterjdb avatar Oct 09 '20 07:10 wouterjdb

Due to the large number of observations the new ERT storage doesn't work very well either. This issue therefore has an impact on #265

wouterjdb avatar Nov 26 '20 07:11 wouterjdb

@edubarrosTNO Will look at resampling options for the obs file creation.

wouterjdb avatar Nov 26 '20 09:11 wouterjdb