FireflyMobile
FireflyMobile copied to clipboard
emansih
Apps hangs permanently on first auth setup, then crashes on startup
Firefly III Server Version:
5.6.14
Firefly III Mobile Version:
5.0.6
Android Version:
12
Device Information:
- BRAND: Samsung Galaxy
- MODEL: S10+
Expected Behavior
App should authenticate and login normally
Current Behavior
My setup is as follows:
- Self hosted Firefly instance in an LXC Debian 11 container, thats behind a firewall which I access through NAT Port Forwarding, with a self signed HTTPs certificate. The port forwarding is not 1:1, I translate an outside port to the inside 443 port. Also, I use the URL with the IP address and port number, no name resolution.
After the first successful authentication, the app hangs permanently, either in "Almost there!" with PAT, or the permanent spinning circle in OAuth. After closing the app (either clearing cache or not), the app crashes on startup, until all data in storage is removed.
Steps to Reproduce
Try to setup the first user authentication.
REPORT_ID=2f385eff-4992-4d6d-8751-dfef5993f4ef APP_VERSION_NAME=5.0.6 PHONE_MODEL=SM-G975F BRAND=samsung PRODUCT=beyond2ltexx ANDROID_VERSION=12 BUILD_CONFIG= STACK_TRACE=java.util.NoSuchElementException: Char sequence is empty. at xyz.hisname.fireflyiii.ui.HomeActivity.$r8$lambda$m5_BfCzbKopEcr4W8HSTQOYhFWo(HomeActivity.kt:15) at xyz.hisname.fireflyiii.ui.HomeActivity$$ExternalSyntheticLambda5.onChanged(Unknown Source:10) at androidx.lifecycle.LiveData.considerNotify(LiveData.java:6) at androidx.lifecycle.LiveData.dispatchingValue(LiveData.java:8) at androidx.lifecycle.LiveData.setValue(LiveData.java:4) at androidx.lifecycle.MutableLiveData.setValue(MutableLiveData.java:1) at androidx.lifecycle.LiveData$1.run(LiveData.java:5) at android.os.Handler.handleCallback(Handler.java:938) at android.os.Handler.dispatchMessage(Handler.java:99) at android.os.Looper.loopOnce(Looper.java:226) at android.os.Looper.loop(Looper.java:313) at android.app.ActivityThread.main(ActivityThread.java:8633) at java.lang.reflect.Method.invoke(Native Method) at com.android.internal.os.RuntimeInit$MethodAndArgsCaller.run(RuntimeInit.java:567) at com.android.internal.os.ZygoteInit.main(ZygoteInit.java:1133)
LOGCAT=--------- beginning of main
02-11 14:35:51.971 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: stopped(true) old=false
02-11 14:35:51.981 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): isMultiSplitHandlerRequested: windowingMode=1 isFullscreen=true isPopOver=false isHidden=false skipActivityType=false isHandlerType=true this: DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:35:51.981 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): removeMultiSplitHandler: no exist. decor=DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:35:57.110 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:35:57.112 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:35:57.113 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:36:35.373 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: handleAppVisibility mAppVisible=false visible=true
02-11 14:36:35.383 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:36:35.386 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: Relayout returned: old=(0,0,720,1520) new=(0,0,720,1520) req=(720,1520)4 dur=3 res=0x1 s={false 0} ch=false fn=-1
02-11 14:36:35.386 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: stopped(false) old=true
02-11 14:36:35.388 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): isMultiSplitHandlerRequested: windowingMode=1 isFullscreen=true isPopOver=false isHidden=false skipActivityType=false isHandlerType=true this: DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:36:35.388 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): removeMultiSplitHandler: no exist. decor=DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:36:35.388 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: stopped(false) old=false
02-11 14:36:35.391 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): isMultiSplitHandlerRequested: windowingMode=1 isFullscreen=true isPopOver=false isHidden=false skipActivityType=false isHandlerType=true this: DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:36:35.391 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): removeMultiSplitHandler: no exist. decor=DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:36:35.403 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:36:35.411 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: Relayout returned: old=(0,0,720,1520) new=(0,0,720,1520) req=(720,1520)0 dur=5 res=0x7 s={true 532098878576} ch=true fn=-1
02-11 14:36:35.411 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: [DP] dp(1) 1 android.view.ViewRootImpl.reportNextDraw:11261 android.view.ViewRootImpl.performTraversals:4088 android.view.ViewRootImpl.doTraversal:2832
02-11 14:36:35.412 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): eglCreateWindowSurface
02-11 14:36:35.434 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: [DP] pdf(0) 1 android.view.ViewRootImpl.lambda$createFrameCompleteCallback$3$ViewRootImpl:4846 android.view.ViewRootImpl$$ExternalSyntheticLambda15.run:6 android.os.Handler.handleCallback:938
02-11 14:36:35.434 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: [DP] rdf()
02-11 14:36:35.434 D/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: reportDrawFinished (fn: -1)
02-11 14:36:35.467 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: MSG_WINDOW_FOCUS_CHANGED 1 1
02-11 14:36:35.494 D/InputMethodManager(15429): startInputInner - Id : 0
02-11 14:36:35.494 I/InputMethodManager(15429): startInputInner - mService.startInputOrWindowGainedFocus
02-11 14:36:50.992 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:51.036 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:57.346 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:57.428 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:57.520 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:57.603 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:57.746 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:57.795 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:57.979 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:58.012 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:58.205 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:58.253 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:58.413 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:58.453 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:58.621 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:58.662 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:58.821 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:58.878 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:59.012 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:59.062 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:59.196 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:59.254 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:59.403 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:59.454 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:59.605 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:59.678 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:36:59.846 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 0
02-11 14:36:59.895 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: ViewPostIme pointer 1
02-11 14:37:01.002 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: MSG_WINDOW_FOCUS_CHANGED 0 1
02-11 14:37:01.386 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: handleAppVisibility mAppVisible=true visible=false
02-11 14:37:01.402 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface called with nullptr
02-11 14:37:01.402 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): setSurface() destroyed EGLSurface
02-11 14:37:01.402 D/OpenGLRenderer(15429): destroyEglSurface
02-11 14:37:01.406 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: Relayout returned: old=(0,0,720,1520) new=(0,0,720,1520) req=(720,1520)8 dur=3 res=0x5 s={false 0} ch=true fn=1547
02-11 14:37:01.406 I/ViewRootImpl@8a76befAuthActivity: stopped(true) old=false
02-11 14:37:01.409 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): isMultiSplitHandlerRequested: windowingMode=1 isFullscreen=true isPopOver=false isHidden=false skipActivityType=false isHandlerType=true this: DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:37:01.409 I/MSHandlerLifeCycle(15429): removeMultiSplitHandler: no exist. decor=DecorView@89b3ebe[]
02-11 14:37:01.412 D/InputTransport(15429): Input channel destroyed: 'ClientS', fd=116
02-11 14:37:05.015 E/name.fireflyii(17295): Not starting debugger since process cannot load the jdwp agent.
02-11 14:37:05.018 E/USNET (17295): USNET: appName: xyz.hisname.fireflyiii
02-11 14:37:05.020 D/ProcessState(17295): Binder ioctl to enable oneway spam detection failed: Invalid argument
02-11 14:37:05.025 D/ActivityThread(17295): setConscryptValidator
02-11 14:37:05.026 D/ActivityThread(17295): setConscryptValidator - put
--------- beginning of system
02-11 14:37:05.035 D/ActivityThread(17295): handleBindApplication()++ app=xyz.hisname.fireflyiii
02-11 14:37:05.037 D/CompatibilityChangeReporter(17295): Compat change id reported: 171979766; UID 10436; state: DISABLED
02-11 14:37:05.054 W/name.fireflyii(17295): Entry not found
02-11 14:37:05.057 W/name.fireflyii(17295): JIT profile information will not be recorded: profile file does not exist.
02-11 14:37:05.064 V/GraphicsEnvironment(17295): ANGLE Developer option for 'xyz.hisname.fireflyiii' set to: 'default'
02-11 14:37:05.064 V/GraphicsEnvironment(17295): App is not on the allowlist for updatable production driver.
02-11 14:37:05.066 D/LoadedApk(17295): LoadedApk::makeApplication() appContext.mOpPackageName=xyz.hisname.fireflyiii appContext.mBasePackageName=xyz.hisname.fireflyiii
02-11 14:37:05.066 D/NetworkSecurityConfig(17295): Using Network Security Config from resource network_security_config debugBuild: false
02-11 14:37:05.072 D/NetworkSecurityConfig(17295): Using Network Security Config from resource network_security_config debugBuild: false
02-11 14:37:05.075 D/WM-WrkMgrInitializer(17295): Initializing WorkManager with default configuration.
02-11 14:37:05.076 W/name.fireflyii(17295): Accessing hidden field Ljava/util/Collections$SynchronizedCollection;->mutex:Ljava/lang/Object; (max-target-o, reflection, denied)
02-11 14:37:05.076 W/name.fireflyii(17295): Accessing hidden method Ljava/util/Collections$SynchronizedSet;->
IS_SILENT=false USER_CRASH_DATE=2022-02-11T14:37:14.608+01:00
I get the same when installing from Play Store or F-Droid. Interestingly, I don't get the error when building the 5.0.6 on my own and installing the debug version.
EDIT: After, clearing the app data and trying to authenticate again I got the error with a more helpful stacktrace:
02-26 22:10:55.228 26591 26591 E AndroidRuntime: java.util.NoSuchElementException: Char sequence is empty.
02-26 22:10:55.228 26591 26591 E AndroidRuntime: at kotlin.text.StringsKt___StringsKt.first(_Strings.kt:71)
02-26 22:10:55.228 26591 26591 E AndroidRuntime: at xyz.hisname.fireflyiii.ui.HomeActivity.setUpHeader$lambda-9(HomeActivity.kt:175)
...
It seems that it tries to get the first letter from the user email to render the logo and the email is empty.
After deleting any Photorius accounts from the Android Settings and authenticating again there was no error.
EDIT2:
Actually the problem seems to be that if one authentication attempt fails, an Android Account has been created for the device, but the activeUserEmail has not been set for that account hash. So when the user tries to authenticate again and they succeed, a new Android Account is created but the app tries to render all accounts in the drawer using the first letter of their email and since it can't find an email for the previous account it fails.
@teldosas nice investigation! This issue has been bugging me for some time and I could not replicate it. I am more than happy to take a PR.
@emansih Nice! Would it make sense to move the creation of the account after the authentication succeeds?
EDIT: or I could just remove any accounts that don't have an email set
Thanks for the help, and I'm glad the creator of the app is here, and this long issue can be fixed and solved in the Play Store App.
I wish I had some more experience in Kotlin, so I could help.
Please let me know whatever kind of help is needed, I am happy to test a new version whenever these fixes are done :)
Same here!
I fixed it deleting all my app-related android accounts. (And seting up again)
I had aprox. 5 android accounts... Maybe because I failed attempting to add my server a lot of times.
