icons icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
icons copied to clipboard

Update mouse icon to look like most mice

Open philipzae opened this issue 4 years ago • 9 comments

Prerequisites

  • [X] I have searched open and closed issues for duplicates.

Feature

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. Yes the mouse icon isn't easily understood at small sizes found in menus and doesn't like most mice used by the majority of people.

Describe the solution you'd like Designing a new icon or utilizing one from another theme

Existing work The humanity icon theme has a design that could be used. preview

Describe alternatives you've considered Switching the icon theme to something else

Additional context I've filed this bug downstream with Xubuntu's default icon theme as well. https://github.com/shimmerproject/elementary-xfce/issues/214


Want to back this issue? Post a bounty on it! We accept bounties via Bountysource.

philipzae avatar Apr 21 '20 09:04 philipzae

I believe the current mouse icon falsely implies likeness to the Apple Magic Mouse, which is an uncommon mouse that most users are not familiar with. I do think there should be a better mouse icon, one that is simple and easy for all users to understand without association to a certain brand.

alfonsojon avatar May 05 '20 04:05 alfonsojon

I agree. Are you going to try to design one? If not, I'll be looking into it.

Furthermore, I'd like to add that this particular icon in the system settings also uses an Apple Magic Mouse. image

Fatih20 avatar May 06 '20 14:05 Fatih20

I agree. Are you going to try to design one? If not, I'll be looking into it.

Please go ahead and do so, while we await for the elementary team.

philipzae avatar May 06 '20 15:05 philipzae

(came here from the downstream issue)

I would like to add some references:

Adwaita

16x16 48x48 / Scalable
Mouse Mouse
Touchpad Touchpad

Yaru

16x16 48x48 / Sacalable
Mouse Mouse
Touchpad X

Papirus

16x16 48x48 / Scalable
Mouse Mouse
Touchpad Touchpad

Elementary Human Interface Guidelines #Iconography

marcosins avatar May 06 '20 16:05 marcosins

I've designed a prototype, what do you think? image

Fatih20 avatar May 09 '20 02:05 Fatih20

@Fatih20 is that a top view of a mouse, as i'm not seeing it. Did you check the elementary HIG, as i'm not sure that the shadow at the bottom would be something that would be suitable.

philipzae avatar May 09 '20 02:05 philipzae

@Fatih20 is that a top view of a mouse, as i'm not seeing it. Did you check the elementary HIG, as i'm not sure that the shadow at the bottom would be something that would be suitable.

Yes it is. No, that's not the shadow, that's just part of the mouse.

Fatih20 avatar May 09 '20 02:05 Fatih20

Here is an alternative. image

Fatih20 avatar May 09 '20 02:05 Fatih20

I'll await someone with knowledge of the HIG to suggest changes.

philipzae avatar May 09 '20 12:05 philipzae