houston icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
houston copied to clipboard

Provide screenshot suggestions

Open desiderantes opened this issue 5 years ago • 2 comments

Generating screenshots for applications would be a really nice feature, and creating a safe default picture in case there's something wrong with other screenshots.

There's discussion about this feature here, but the implementation discussed has the following problems:

  • Depends on X11 tooling (I have no info on Wayland alternatives)
  • Provides barebones GTK+ theming (I guess this is where Houston would shine)
  • Does not deals with apps with long startup time, apps with initial steps before the main window, nor apps with required configuration

Want to back this issue? Post a bounty on it! We accept bounties via Bountysource.

desiderantes avatar Jul 17 '18 20:07 desiderantes

We've discussed this before, but the result is usually the same: Auto-generating screenshots will almost always yield a worse result than the developer (who knows their application and which screens are useful to users) taking and picking them. Given that, I don't know that the tooling required to automatically take screenshots (plus the edge cases it introduces) is worth investing time and effort into right now.

cassidyjames avatar Jul 17 '18 20:07 cassidyjames

There's also the problem of apps being content-less. A screenshot of an empty Video player isn't very interesting. I'm leaning towards this being a "Won't fix" since it's far less effort to just instruct the developer to take a screenshot

danirabbit avatar Jul 17 '18 20:07 danirabbit