element-meta icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
element-meta copied to clipboard

Element Call product name is translated (where it shouldn't)

Open kongo09 opened this issue 9 months ago • 2 comments

Steps to reproduce

  1. Switch to German language
  2. Enter a room
  3. Click on the video calling symbol

Outcome

What did you expect?

See two options

  • Legacy Call
  • Element Call

What happened instead?

Image

Element Call is a product name and should not be translated

Operating system

Windows 11

Application version

Version von Element: 1.11.96 Krypto-Version: Rust SDK 0.10.0 (3cc301d), Vodozemac 0.9.0

How did you install the app?

element.io

Homeserver

element.io

Will you send logs?

No

kongo09 avatar Mar 31 '25 10:03 kongo09

I'm not sure that's correct, if I'm a user which can only read non-roman alphabets then printing Element Call may be wholly illegible and inaccessible

t3chguy avatar Mar 31 '25 12:03 t3chguy

I'm not sure that's correct, if I'm a user which can only read non-roman alphabets then printing Element Call may be wholly illegible and inaccessible

When translating to a non-Latin written language, if this string is used as a symbol, I personally think it should not be translated. There are many examples of failures in this regard (take English to Chinese as an example):

  • "Windows (OS name)" -> 视窗; 窗户 Even in China, in most cases, "Windows" is used instead of "视窗" to refer to Microsoft's operating system.

  • "Home" -> 主页; 家

  • "Enter" -> 回车; 进入 These are the names of several keys on the keyboard. Like the above, most of the time what you see on the keyboard is English, and it should not be translated either. This is also an existing problem in Element Web's localization.

Not all English words can be perfectly translated into other languages. In summary, "Element Call" as a symbol, forced translation will only make people confused and stiff.

YamatoRyou avatar Mar 31 '25 21:03 YamatoRyou