element-android icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
element-android copied to clipboard

Reply text not visible when receiving reply to a message

Open ehuelsmann opened this issue 11 months ago • 14 comments

Steps to reproduce

I'm doing nothing. Just reading the channel. Others are replying to my message, but I can't see the reply, only the "repetition" of the message replied to. See below. Btw, in the web client I can see that the reply was not actually empty.

Screenshot_20250106-194748

Outcome

What did you expect?

I expected to see the most important part of the message: the reply sent by the OP, not just the text of the original message (the one replied to).

What happened instead?

I'm not seeing the text I did expect to see.

Ps: in response to the two questions below: I have sent logs. And I would provide a PR if I knew how to code an Android app.

Your phone model

Motorola g73 5g

Operating system version

Android 14

Application version and app store

From Play Store.

Homeserver

Matrix.org

Will you send logs?

No

Are you willing to provide a PR?

No

ehuelsmann avatar Jan 06 '25 18:01 ehuelsmann

+1 also experience this since a few weeks.

Workaround for now: If you long press the message you can still read the reply.

weebl2000 avatar Jan 06 '25 21:01 weebl2000

have this issue too, renders reactions useless for users on mobile (or I have to tell people to long press)

maybe https://github.com/element-hq/element-android/pull/8947 doesnt work? / was this commit pushed to play store? I am still on 1.6.24

Destroyer avatar Jan 07 '25 12:01 Destroyer

I just tried and downloaded the apk from the latest release on GitHub to upgrade the app. With the new version the rendering issue is resolved. The devs have to point out why this release hasn't been published to Google Play

promasu avatar Jan 08 '25 08:01 promasu

I am also experiencing this issue.

Enoch247 avatar Jan 08 '25 11:01 Enoch247

Same here with Android 14 on moto g73 5G / Play Store but there are several friends with different devices with the same bug.

rbt2024 avatar Jan 09 '25 21:01 rbt2024

+1 Android 14 / F-Droid release 1.6.24, and also one more device with Android 8....

masscream avatar Jan 10 '25 08:01 masscream

This issue is a duplicate of #8947. The version with this fix (1.6.26) is so far not available today Google Play thus only available via direct download from GitHub.

promasu avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 promasu

in Google Play is only version 1.6.24

rbt2024 avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 rbt2024

@promasu actually, #8947 is a PR, not an issue. I'll agree that this is a duplicate of #8162 .

ehuelsmann avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 ehuelsmann

Publishing the version with the fix will be really helpful: it's been like this for months now.

ehuelsmann avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 ehuelsmann

@ehuelsmann you are totally right. Grabbed the wrong id :D

promasu avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 promasu

@Half-Shot any chance of having version 1.6.26 published on Google Play? These replies not showing are quite crippling: the mentioned workaround of long-pressing only works for short responses.

ehuelsmann avatar Jan 15 '25 10:01 ehuelsmann

It is available in f-droid now ! Simply tell f-droid to get the beta version and it works

mccoys avatar Jan 15 '25 13:01 mccoys

I am using 1.6.28 from play store and still experience this issue as of today (actually a completely new phone where the app just has been setup)

tuximail avatar Feb 03 '25 14:02 tuximail