thorium-reader icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
thorium-reader copied to clipboard

Read aloud is "skipping" through pages without media overlay implementation

Open brianagina opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

When the read aloud is activated, pages without media overlay implementation in the reading order are "skipped". This presents an issue in EPUB publications with pages that have and do not have media overlay implementation in the reading order. Each page without media overlay implementation is "skipped" through, barely few seconds after being opened. It is challenging to stop the read aloud when the pages are being "skipped".

  • Can we have the thorium-reader stop read aloud when on a page without media overlay implementation so that the page is not "skipped" through?
  • Is there a work around in the EPUB code?

brianagina avatar May 04 '22 11:05 brianagina

Hello, this is actually a feature, not a bug. The previous behaviour was to quickly skip non-narrated pages, but this was problematic in certain cases such as illustrated children's books with visual spreads adjacent to textual / spoken content. Do you know how other reading systems present EPUB3 Media Overlays that have narration "holes" in them? Do they ignore the documents by skipping them in the reading order? I remember Apple iBooks pausing for 2s on non-narrated pages, but this was FXL and their implementation may have changed since...

danielweck avatar May 04 '22 20:05 danielweck

Do you know how other reading systems present EPUB3 Media Overlays that have narration "holes" in them?

  • Quite similar behavior .The discontinued Adobe Digital Editions and iBooks also skip through non-narrated pages. I had a similar experience on iBooks having tested recently. When can this feature be part of the roadmap?

brianagina avatar Aug 05 '22 11:08 brianagina

Moving this feature discussion to a ... discussion :)

danielweck avatar Aug 26 '22 15:08 danielweck